The Psychological Sustainability of Family Firms: Work–Family Spillover and Organizational Trust in an Italian Manufacturing SME Teresa Galanti; Morena Santoriello; Camilla Canonico; Michela Cortini Sustainability · 2026-10-07 CC BY 4.0 · https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Source: https://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/18/19/10183 Abstract Background: Family firms are a pillar of most national economies, yet the overlap between family and business systems that defines them is also a source of affective strain and group-level tension that can spread across both domains. Sustainable organization management in family firms therefore depends not only on economic performance but on how governance, succession, and daily relational dynamics are managed psychologically. This study examines how the psychological blurring of family and work boundaries affects governance, succession readiness, and employee well-being in a small Italian family-owned manufacturing firm. Methods: A mixed-methods design combined semi-structured interviews with family members active in management (analyzed using conventional qualitative content analysis) with a structured survey administered to non-family employees, measuring supervisor and coworker support, perceived nepotism, organizational trust, organizational identification, burnout, turnover intention, self-rated performance, and job satisfaction. Results: Family members described persistent, largely unmanaged spillover between generational conflict over innovation, decision-making authority, and an informally anticipated but never formalized succession. Employees, by contrast, reported a generally positive climate, but perceived nepotism—although low on average—was consistently associated with lower organizational trust. Conclusions: Family-level emotional dynamics and employee-level perceptions of fairness constitute two only partly overlapping sources of risk to the sustainable management of small family firms, with direct implications for succession planning and human resource practices. 1. Introduction Family firms are estimated to account for around two-thirds of businesses worldwide, 70–90% of annual global GDP, and 50–80% of jobs in most countries, making them the predominant organizational form in most national economies [ 1 ]. This scale is matched by a structural peculiarity: family firms combine two systems—the family and the business—that are formally distinct but functionally interdependent [ 2 ]. This overlap is not incidental: it is what makes family firms different from other organizations, generating a source of competitive advantage and a source of psychological vulnerability simultaneously, because roles, authority, and affective bonds are exercised by the same people across both domains [ 2 ]. Despite the size and economic relevance of this organizational form, empirical studies that examine family-level and employee-level psychological dynamics jointly remain scarce: most family-business research draws either on the family’s own account of governance or on employee surveys, but rarely triangulates the two [ 3 , 4 ], and even more rarely frames the question in terms of the psychological sustainability of the organization rather than its financial performance alone. Methodologically, family-business research has long been criticized for relying on owner- or family-centric designs that leave the non-family workforce unheard [ 3 ], a gap only recently addressed by instruments explicitly built to capture non-family employees’ own perceptions of the family’s influence on the firm rather than inferring them from the family’s self-report [ 4 ]. This study addresses that gap through a mixed-methods case study of a small, Italian, family-owned manufacturing firm, combining narrative interviews with family members active in management and a structured survey of the firm’s non-family employees. Specifically, triangulating these two perspectives reveals that family-level and employee-level threats to psychological sustainability are not the same phenomenon observed from two angles, but two distinct, only partly overlapping sources of risk—a divergence that neither an exclusively family-centered design could have documented. The aim is twofold: (a) to describe how family members experience the permeability of the boundary between family and work, generational differences, and the (informal) succession process; and (b) to examine whether and how these family-level dynamics are visible—or invisible—from the standpoint of the employees who work alongside, but outside, the owning family. Because family and business roles overlap in this setting, the study is inherently concerned with affective and group-level processes: how emotions generated within the family group spill into the workplace, and how the family, as a group, is perceived by the distinct group of non-family employees. In doing so, the study speaks directly to two pillars of sustainable organization management: succession planning as a leadership practice for long-term organizational continuity, and perceived nepotism as a potential threat to psychological safety among non-family employees. The paper’s central theoretical proposition is that these two pillars are not independent: family members’ continued engagement with the firm is best understood through a stewardship lens, oriented toward legacy and collective identity, whereas non-family employees’ evaluation of the same firm is better captured by an agency-and fairness-oriented lens, attentive to monitoring and equitable treatment. Rather than treating stewardship and agency/fairness perspectives as competing accounts of family firms in general, we advance this distinction as a within-firm, across-stakeholder theoretical contribution: the same organizational reality is filtered through two systematically different psychological lenses depending on one’s position relative to the owning family, a distinction that organizes the empirical analysis and discussion that follow. Building on this proposition, the study is guided by two research questions: RQ1. How do family members active in management experience the permeability of work-family boundaries and the succession process? RQ2. How do non-family employees perceive organizational fairness, trust, and the influence of owning on daily practice? 2.1. Governance in Family Firms: Agency Theory, Stewardship Theory, and the Bifurcation Bias Two theoretical traditions have historically framed the governance of family firms. Agency theory treats the firm as a nexus of contracts between principals and agents whose interests can diverge, generating monitoring costs whenever ownership and management are separated, and remains an empirically valid perspective for studying cooperative structures more generally [ 5 , 6 ]. Stewardship theory offers an alternative reading more consistent with family-firm dynamics: it depicts organizational members as collectivist, prosocial, and pro-organizational, identifying the success of the firm with their own success rather than pursuing self-interested opportunism [ 7 ]. These two traditions are widely regarded as the dominant theoretical lenses in family-business governance research, although complementary perspectives—discussed below—offer additional explanatory value. Applied to family firms specifically, this alternative model of man suggests that family members may act out of self-actualizing motives rather than purely self-serving ones, complicating any straightforward application of agency costs to family-owned businesses [ 8 ]. Consistent with this view, comparative work on family governance shows that the specific configuration of ownership, leadership, and later-generation involvement—rather than family involvement as such—determines whether a family firm behaves in an agency-consistent or a stewardship-consistent manner, with direct consequences for resource-allocation decisions and performance [ 9 ]. More recent work reconciles the two traditions through the concept of the bifurcation bias: family firms tend to treat family and non-family resources—particularly human resources—asymmetrically, extending steward-like trust to family members while evaluating non-family employees through a more agency-like, monitoring-based lens; the prosperity and long-term reliability of the firm depends on containing this bias [ 10 ]. This distinction is directly relevant to the present study, which examines both family members (who may experience the firm in stewardship terms) and non-family employees (who may experience it, at least partly, in agency-related terms of fairness and monitoring), and reflects a broader trend in the field toward reconciling competing theoretical accounts of the family firm rather than treating them as mutually exclusive [ 11 ]. 2.2. Socioemotional Wealth A third, complementary perspective, the socioemotional wealth (SEW) approach, argues that family owners do not only pursue financial returns but also protect non-financial, affect-related endowments—family control, identity, and continuity—even at the cost of foregoing profitable opportunities [ 12 ]. These non-financial priorities are central to understanding why family firms may resist innovation, delay succession, or tolerate inefficient arrangements that a purely economic model would not predict, and they have since been elaborated into a broader set of dimensions encompassing family control and influence, identification with the firm, binding social ties, emotional attachment, and renewal of family bonds through succession [ 13 ]. Complementary valuation-oriented work formalizes this idea by proposing that the total value family owners assign to their firm combines financial worth with emotional returns and emotional costs, which can lead owners to retain or exit a business for reasons a purely financial valuation would not capture [ 14 ], while research on transgenerational control intentions shows that family CEOs value their firm more highly the stronger their intention to pass control on to the next generation, linking SEW directly to the succession process discussed in Section 2.3 [ 15 ]. 2.3. Succession as a Psychological and Relational Process Succession is widely regarded as the single most critical transition in the life of a family firm, because it simultaneously reallocates power, ownership, responsibility, and identity [ 16 ]. A large body of research shows that the readiness of the incumbent generation to step back, and the willingness of the successor to commit, matter more for a successful transition than the mere existence of an heir [ 16 , 17 , 18 ]: succession planning is more strongly driven by the successor’s own propensity to take over than by the incumbent’s initiative [ 16 ]; successor commitment itself is a multidimensional construct resting on affective, normative, calculative, and imperative bases that predict whether a designated heir actually follows through [ 17 ]; and, at the founder’s end, succession unfolds as a gradual mutual role adjustment in which the incumbent’s willingness to relinquish authority is as decisive as the successor’s readiness to assume it [ 18 ]. Successive generations are also frequently described as agents of innovation, introducing new technologies and managerial practices that can clash with the founder’s experience-based, more risk-averse orientation, producing recurrent intergenerational tension around digitalization and change [ 19 ]. 2.4. Work–Family Conflict, Spillover, and Intragroup Conflict A second strand of research, only partly integrated with the family-business literature, concerns the psychological spillover between work and family roles. Work–family conflict arises when the demands of one role make it difficult to fulfil the demands of the other, through time-based, strain-based, or behavior-based mechanisms [ 20 ], and emotions generated in one domain “spill over” into the other, affecting well-being and relational quality regardless of the direction of the spillover [ 21 ]. In family firms, where the same individuals occupy family and business roles simultaneously, the boundary between the two domains is structurally more permeable than in non-family organizations, which makes spillover not an occasional risk but a standing feature of daily functioning. Whether conflict among family members is functional or dysfunctional for the organization also depends on its nature: task conflict, centered on divergent views about goals and strategies, can improve decision quality, while relationship conflict, rooted in personal incompatibility, tends to erode trust and cooperation [ 22 ]. 2.5. Family Relationships, Conflict, and Nepotism Toward Non-Family Employees A stewardship-based reading of family relationships suggests that altruism among family members can reduce relationship conflict and support a more participative strategy process, contributing to firm performance [ 23 ]; at the same time, conflict within the owning family is not inherently harmful—when it centers on divergent views about the business rather than on personal incompatibility, it can improve decision quality and even become a source of competitive advantage for the firm [ 24 ]. This body of work, however, is framed almost entirely from the standpoint of the family itself. Research on nepotism and favoritism offers a complementary, employee-centered perspective: when promotion and reward decisions are perceived as based on kinship rather than merit, non-family employees report higher job stress and lower job satisfaction, independent of the objective frequency of favoritism [ 25 ]. Read together with the bifurcation-bias construct introduced in Section 2.1 [ 10 ], this literature suggests that the same family closeness that supports stewardship-consistent behavior among family members can translate into perceived unfairness for those outside the family, a tension this study examines empirically by contrasting the family’s own account of its relationship with employees against employees’ reports of perceived nepotism and organizational trust. 2.6. Toward a Sustainability Perspective on Family Firms: Research Gap and Aim of the Study From a sustainability perspective, the psychological foundations of family-firm management are not a peripheral concern but a precondition for the long-term viability of these organizations: a firm that cannot manage generational transition, that generates chronic strain in its own owning family, or that is perceived as unfair by its non-family workforce is a firm whose human capital—and therefore whose capacity to persist across generations—is at risk, independently of its financial performance. Understanding family-firm sustainability as a socio-psychological construct, alongside the more familiar economic and environmental readings, is an emerging concern in the literature [ 26 ]. Following Di Fabio’s conceptualization of the psychology of sustainability as the optimization and regeneration of psychological resources at individual, group, and organizational levels [ 27 ], this study operationalizes the psychological sustainability of the case firm along three empirical indicators: depletion of psychological resources, captured by employee burnout and turnover intention; preservation of relational resources, captured by organizational trust and organizational identification; and continuity of leadership, captured by the readiness and formalization of succession planning. A firm sustains itself psychologically to the extent that it limits the first while supporting the second and third. The theoretical strands reviewed above—governance and the bifurcation bias, socioemotional wealth, succession, and work–family spillover—are typically studied separately and, within family-business research, typically from the family’s own standpoint. The present study integrates them empirically by triangulating the family’s narrative account with a structured, independent measure of how non-family employees experience the same organization. 3.1. Research Design To address research questions, a convergent mixed-methods, single-case design was adopted [ 28 , 29 ], combining a qualitative study (interviews with family members) with a quantitative study (a structured survey of non-family employees) conducted within the same organization. Consistent with case-study logic, the quantitative component was not intended to produce statistically generalizable estimates, given the small workforce, but to provide a systematic, external point of comparison against the family’s own narrative, in a design oriented toward analytic depth rather than sample extension. A qualitative, interview-based single-case design has previously been used to trace how sustainability is integrated into strategy and control systems within an Italian family firm [ 30 ], supporting the appropriateness of an in-depth single-case approach for examining sustainability-related dynamics within this organizational form. This single-case design follows a phenomenon-driven case-selection logic [ 31 ], in which the case is chosen for its capacity to illuminate a phenomenon of theoretical interest—the divergence between family members’ and non-family employees’ psychological experience of the same organization—rather than for statistical representativeness [ 32 ]. The case firm was selected because it combines a multi-generational ownership structure, an unresolved and informally anticipated succession process observable in real time, and full research access to both family members and non-family employees. 3.2. Case Description The case company (referred to here as “the Company” to protect the identity of the family and of individual respondents) is a small manufacturing firm based in central Italy, active in sheet-metal cutting and processing. At the time of data collection, the Company employed approximately 30 people and had recently relocated to a larger production facility to support its expansion into automotive components. The firm’s trajectory through repeated financial and sectoral crises is broadly consistent with evidence that organizations operating in emergency or high-uncertainty contexts rely on informal trust and risk-management practices, alongside formal ones, to sustain a climate in which employees and management can learn from both success and failure [ 33 ]. 3.3. Study 1: Qualitative Interviews with Family Members Participants were the three family members holding management responsibilities in the firm: the second-generation owner (male, 60, 12 years in the firm), his spouse (female, 57, 12 years, administrative manager), and their son (male, 27, 9 years, company administrator, third generation). All family members active in governance were included, given the study’s interest in intra-family decision-making; non-family employees were excluded from this component and addressed separately through the survey ( Section 3.4 ). The qualitative sample comprises all three family members holding managerial roles in the firm at the time of data collection, rather than a subsample drawn from a larger eligible pool. Given this study’s aim of examining family-level dynamics within a single, well-defined organizational unit, sample adequacy is better evaluated through the lens of information power [ 34 ] than through saturation: the narrow, specific population, the study’s tightly defined aim, and the strength and specificity of the dialogue obtained together support a small sample size. We nonetheless acknowledge that the resulting themes are likely to reflect this family’s configuration and history and should be interpreted as analytically transferable insights rather than as claims about family firms in general. Table 1 reports participants’ socio-demographic characteristics. The interview was designed following the Narrative Interview approach [ 35 ], covering the firm’s history, involvement of the participant, decision-making processes, generational differences, succession, spillover between work and family life, and the relationship with non-family employees (the full protocol is reported in Appendix A ). Given the sensitivity of some topics, questions were administered in written form through Qualtrics rather than face-to-face, allowing participants to respond without time pressure or interviewer influence. This is a substantive departure from Atkinson’s original narrative interview method, which presupposes a dialogic interaction with follow-up probing that can elicit richer, more elaborated accounts; written self-administration forgoes this responsive probing and the paralinguistic cues (tone, hesitation, timing) an interviewer would otherwise draw on, and plausibly yields more concise, more deliberately composed narratives than a spoken interview would. However, consistent with broader comparisons of interview techniques, asynchronous written formats trade some conversational depth for greater respondent control over disclosure and reduced interviewer influence [ 36 ], a trade-off judged appropriate here given the sensitivity, for family members, of discussing intra-family conflict, but one that likely limits the depth and spontaneity of the narrative data relative to a dialogic interview, and is revisited as a limitation. Participants were assigned anonymized codes (INT_01–INT_03) used throughout the reporting of results. Two coders performed conventional (inductive) qualitative content analysis [ 37 ]. An initial codebook was developed inductively from the first interview and then applied to the remaining two; coding discrepancies, affecting fewer than 10% of codes, were resolved through consensus discussion between the two coders, with a third researcher acting as arbiter when needed. The analytic progression from raw data to interpretive themes followed two explicit stages, illustrated for each theme in Table 2 . First, each interview was segmented into meaning units, and first-order codes were assigned close to participants’ own wording (e.g., generational_differences , resistance_to_change ). Second, codes referring to a shared underlying concept were grouped, through iterative comparison and discussion between coders, into six broader themes representing recurring patterns across the interviews. This two-tier progression is consistent with the conventional content analysis approach adopted here [ 37 ], rather than the three-tier structure associated with the Gioia methodology (Giaia, Corley & Hamilton, 2013) [ 38 ], which was not adopted in this study given its closer alignment with grounded-theory-building rather than content-analytic aims. Themes were finalized through iterative comparison across all interviews (stepwise replication) [ 39 ]. 3.4. Study 2: Survey of Non-Family Employees The survey was administered online via Qualtrics to all non-family employees; 26 employees completed it in full (response characteristics in Table 3 ). The instrument combined scales adapted from the literature: organizational trust, adapted from the integrative model of organizational trust [ 40 ]; organizational identification, measured with the validated Italian adaptation of the Mael and Ashforth scale [ 41 , 42 ]; job satisfaction and supervisor/coworker support items, adapted from the Michigan Organizational Assessment Questionnaire [ 43 ]; perceived nepotism, adapted from research on nepotism and favoritism in the workplace [ 25 ]; and burnout, measured with the validated Italian version of the 12-item short form of the Burnout Assessment Tool (BAT-12) [ 44 , 45 , 46 ]. Turnover intention was measured with additional items consistent with the Michigan Organizational Assessment Questionnaire [ 43 ]. Finally, self-rated job performance was measured with the Di Fabio & Svicher Self-rated Job Performance scale [ 47 ]. Organizational Identification, burnout and self-rated performance scale was assessed with a validated Italian adaptation available; the remaining scales were translated following established cross-cultural adaptation guidelines [ 48 ]. Table 4 reports the origin, example items and internal consistency estimates of these scales. Missing data were minimal, limited to one respondent who did not complete the self-rated performance scale; descriptive statistics for each scale ( Table 4 ) were therefore computed using all available responses for that scale ( N = 25–26, available-case analysis), and the same pairwise-deletion approach was used for the correlation analyses reported in Section 4.2 and Appendix B . Given the small sample size, typical of case studies of small enterprises, results are reported as exploratory descriptive and correlational patterns rather than as generalizable estimates. Given the number of pairwise correlations examined, p -values were adjusted using the Benjamini–Hochberg false discovery rate procedure ( q = 0.05); correlations are reported as FDR-significant only where they survive this correction. 3.5. Ethical Considerations The study was conducted in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki and approved by the Ethics Committee of the Department of Psychology (approval code: n. 26014, approval date: 21 May 2026). All participants received an information sheet describing the study’s aims and provided informed consent electronically prior to participation; anonymity and confidentiality were guaranteed, and the identity of the firm and of individual family members has been further disguised in this article for publication. A methodological note on researcher positionality is warranted. C.C. is a family member of the owning family of the case company (see Conflicts of Interest) but has never been employed by, or held a decision-making role in, the firm. This dual position offered advantages typical of insider access in family-business research [ 49 ]—in particular, the trust that made a candid account of intra-family tensions possible, consistent with reflexive accounts by researchers investigating their own family-business context [ 50 ]—but also required specific safeguards against social desirability and researcher influence. For this reason, family-member interviews were self-administered in written form via Qualtrics rather than conducted face-to-face, allowing participants to respond independently and without the researcher present; coding and thematic analysis were subsequently performed by two other researchers who have no relationship with the case company, to avoid any influence on the interpretation of the data. A parallel safeguard was applied to the employee survey ( Section 3.4 ): the invitation and informed consent text presented to employees identified the study as an initiative of the university’s Business Psychology Laboratory and named the corresponding author (T.G.), who has no relationship with the case company, as the sole point of contact for questions; C.C. was not identified to employees as a researcher on the project. Participants were explicitly assured that responses would be treated confidentially and anonymously, that no information would be shared with third parties, and that participation was voluntary and could be withdrawn at any time. A further consideration concerns statistical identifiability: with 26 respondents out of a workforce of approximately 30, and with characteristics such as gender and tenure reported in Appendix B , anonymity within the firm itself is inherently fragile—a risk qualitative researchers term a threat to internal, as opposed to external, confidentiality, since colleagues within a small organization may be able to infer identities even when external readers cannot [ 51 ]. To limit this risk, only aggregate descriptive and correlational statistics are reported ( Table 2 , Table 3 , Table 4 and Table 5 and Appendix B ), individual response profiles are never presented, and no demographic value is singled out or combined with a specific survey response in the text; this risk is nonetheless not fully eliminated and is acknowledged as a limitation. 4.1. Thematic Analysis of Family Members’ Narratives Thematic analysis of the interviews generated six interrelated themes: (1) generational differences and openness to innovation; (2) resistance to change; (3) conflict and family mediation; (4) succession as an unresolved process; (5) family and work without boundaries; and (6) emotional attachment to the firm. Table 4 summarizes each theme, its core content, and an illustrative quotation; the themes are discussed in detail in Section 4.1.1 , Section 4.1.2 , Section 4.1.3 , Section 4.1.4 and Section 4.1.5 . 4.1.1. Generational Differences and Resistance to Change Family members converged in describing a persistent contrast between a founder-generation orientation toward experience-based, tangible decision-making and a third-generation orientation toward technological and organizational innovation. INT_01 summarized this divide directly: “My son has a much more open outlook, in step with the times and with new technologies; my husband does not.” The same participant linked this divide explicitly to conflict around digital tools: “Tension and conflict arise above all when new technologies or software need to be introduced […]; for the older generation—my husband—this is very hard to accept, because for him anything that cannot be touched with one’s hands has little value and excessive costs.” INT_03 offered a concrete illustration, noting that a shift from telephone orders to written e-mail confirmations was resisted by the founder-generation figure until repeated advocacy avoided a contractual penalty. These accounts are consistent with findings that successors often act as promoters of innovation within family firms, while incumbents tend to privilege experience-based routines that historically sustained the business [ 19 ]. 4.1.2. Conflict and Family Mediation INT_01 described occupying a structurally central but informal mediating role between the other two family members: “I find myself acting as a mediator between the two, and it is not always easy […] with good will and a stomach of iron on my part we manage, after various considerations, to find a way through.” This account illustrates that conflict inside the family firm is not an exceptional event but a structural feature of daily functioning, consistent with the distinction between task conflict, which can improve decision quality when centered on genuine differences in opinion, and relationship conflict, which is more likely to erode trust when it becomes personal [ 22 ]. 4.1.3. Succession as an Unresolved Process All three participants implicitly recognized the son as the likely future leader of the firm, yet none described a formalized succession agreement. INT_01 framed succession as a gradual, trust-based process: “I hope that, over time, my husband and I can take a step back and leave increasing space and freedom to my son.” INT_02, however, reframed continuity as the successor’s personal choice rather than an inevitability: “If, as I said before, the next generation—my son—decides to continue on this path, it will be his decision.” This combination of implicit designation and absent formal planning is consistent with the literature’s emphasis on the successor’s genuine willingness, rather than mere availability, as a precondition for successful succession [ 16 , 17 , 18 ]. 4.1.4. Family and Work Without Boundaries Participants described substantial permeability between the work and family domains. INT_01 reported: “I try, as much as I can, to turn the page when I get home, but I do not always manage to. When the discussions are heavier than usual, even the most trivial thing at home inevitably triggers an exaggerated reaction—and my daughter, who lives with us but does not work in the firm, unfortunately finds herself having to bear a heavy atmosphere at home.” INT_02 similarly noted: “I try not to talk about work at home, even though it is practically impossible.” These accounts closely match the classic definition of work–family conflict as role pressures that are mutually incompatible [ 20 ] and the spillover mechanism through which affect generated in one domain transfers into the other [ 21 ], while also illustrating that in family firms this transfer extends to relatives who are not themselves employed by the firm. 4.1.5. Emotional Attachment to the Firm Despite the tensions described above, all participants expressed strong emotional and identity-based attachment to the firm. INT_01 stated: “The idea that one day all this will belong only to my son pushes me to grit my teeth a little longer,” while INT_03 attributed his own continued involvement to “a sense of responsibility and love for my mother.” These accounts are consistent with the socioemotional wealth perspective, according to which family owners value the firm as a source of identity, continuity, and family legacy that is not reducible to its financial return [ 12 , 13 ]. 4.2. Survey of Non-Family Employees Descriptive statistics for all scales are reported in Table 5 . All scales showed good internal consistency (Cronbach’s α ranging from 0.76 to 0.94; Table 4 ). Overall, employees reported low perceived nepotism ( M = 1.77 on a 1–5 scale), low burnout ( M = 1.84 on 1–5), and comparatively high organizational trust, organizational identification, and job satisfaction ( M = 8.65 on a 1–10 scale). Correlational analysis revealed two salient patterns (full correlation matrix in Appendix B ). First, although perceived nepotism was low on average, it was consistently associated with a worse organizational climate: it correlated negatively with supervisor support (r = −0.38), coworker support (r = −0.42), and organizational trust (r = −0.61, 95% CI [−0.81, −0.29]). This last association was the only correlational association hypothesized a priori, on the basis of the bifurcation-bias literature ( Section 2.1 ); all other correlations reported here and in Appendix B are exploratory. Given N = 26, this last coefficient carries a wide confidence interval and should be read as indicating a reliably negative association whose precise magnitude cannot be established with this sample. This association survived false discovery rate correction across all 66 pairwise correlations examined ( p = 0.0009, FDR-adjusted), ranking among the most robust associations in the matrix. Second, a cluster of social and relational resources—supervisor support, coworker support, organizational trust, organizational identification, and self-rated performance—correlated positively with one another (r = 0.40 to 0.71), suggesting that, when present, a supportive relational climate functions as a coherent psychological resource; here too, the width of the confidence intervals at this sample size warrants caution in over-interpreting the relative ranking of individual coefficients. Burnout and turnover intention were strongly associated with each other (r = 0.74) but were only weakly associated with the cluster of relational-support variables and with perceived nepotism (r = 0.39, p < 0.10), suggesting that employee strain in this firm may originate from factors not fully captured by the relational-overload narrative that family members themselves described experiencing. 4.3. Integration of Findings Triangulating the two data sources shows both convergence and divergence. Consistent with the family’s own account of a humane, loyalty-based relationship with employees, the survey confirms a broadly positive climate, low burnout, and high job satisfaction and long tenure ( M = 9.2 years). However, the correlational pattern around perceived nepotism introduces a qualification that the family’s narrative alone could not reveal: even modest perceptions of favoritism toward family members are associated with a disproportionate erosion of organizational trust among non-family staff, echoing evidence that employees exposed to perceived favoritism report lower satisfaction and higher stress even when favoritism is not extreme [ 25 ]. This is consistent with the bifurcation-bias mechanism described in Section 2.1 and Section 2.5 , whereby family and non-family resources are evaluated according to different, asymmetric standards inside family firms [ 10 ], a mechanism that can remain invisible to family members even when it shapes how outsiders experience fairness within the same organization. 5. Discussion This case study set out to answer RQ1 and RQ2 by examining, jointly, how family members and non-family employees experience the psychological consequences of family–business overlap in a small manufacturing firm, and to situate these findings within a sustainability perspective on organizational management. Three implications emerge, which are synthesized into an integrative model at the end of this section. First, the family’s account is highly consistent with the socioemotional wealth perspective [ 12 , 13 ]: continued involvement in the firm, even amid recurrent conflict, was justified not in financial terms but through identity, legacy, and relational obligation (“the idea that one day all this will belong only to my son”; “love for my mother”). Continued engagement with one’s work, even under strain, has similarly been shown to function as a resource for reconstructing a coherent professional identity in other contexts of acute disruption [ 52 ], suggesting that the family’s attachment to the firm may serve a comparable identity-sustaining function here. This suggests that sustainable management of family SMEs cannot rely solely on economic incentives or formal governance structures; it must also account for the non-financial, affect-laden goals that drive family members’ decisions, including their tolerance for conflict and their reluctance to formalize succession. Second, succession emerged as an implicitly agreed but explicitly unplanned process, echoing the broader finding that the mere presence of an heir does not guarantee a successful transition, and that planning depends on the incumbent’s willingness to relinquish control and on the successor’s genuine motivation [ 16 , 17 , 18 ]. In this sense, succession planning functions not merely as a legal or administrative transfer but as a leadership practice with direct consequences for organizational sustainability, since an unplanned transition leaves the firm’s psychological and relational continuity, not only its ownership, unresolved. The absence of formal agreements observed here, despite the son’s decade-long involvement and formal administrative role since 2019, is consistent with the well-documented tendency of family firms to postpone succession planning even when a suitable successor is already active in the business—a pattern with direct implications for the long-term sustainability of the organization, since unplanned transitions are associated with greater managerial disruption. Third, and most novel to this study’s design, the two data sources diverge on where psychological risk actually concentrates. For the family, risk is relational and spills from the boardroom into the home, consistent with classic work–family conflict and spillover mechanisms [ 20 , 21 ]. For non-family employees, risk concentrates instead around the perceived fairness of a system in which family and non-family resources may be evaluated on different terms: even at low absolute levels, perceived nepotism was consistently associated with reduced organizational trust in this sample, though the confidence interval around this association is wide given the sample size. From a sustainable-management perspective, this pattern suggests that perceived nepotism operates as a subtle but consequential threat to psychological safety among non-family employees, undermining exactly the kind of trust-based climate that sustainable leadership approaches are meant to cultivate. This divergence indicates that family-firm sustainability initiatives that focus exclusively on managing family dynamics—for instance, mediating intergenerational conflict, as the firm’s matriarch does informally—may leave an important, largely invisible source of employee strain unaddressed: not conflict exposure, but role ambiguity and perceived inequity in how opportunities are allocated between family and non-family staff. These findings substantiate the theoretical proposition advanced in the introduction: the family’s narrative is largely stewardship-consistent internally, while the employee data show that, from the standpoint of non-family staff, the firm simultaneously generates agency-like concerns about fairness and monitoring, particularly around promotion and reward decisions—the very asymmetry captured by the bifurcation-bias construct [ 10 ]. Rather than treating agency theory and stewardship theory [ 5 , 7 ] as mutually exclusive descriptions of the same firm, the empirical pattern confirms that they describe two coexisting subsystems within it—family members acting as stewards toward one another and toward the firm’s legacy, while non-family employees continue to evaluate the organization, at least partly, through an agency-based fairness lens. Synthesis: An Integrative Model of Psychological Sustainability Read together, these three implications can be synthesized into an integrative model ( Figure 1 ) that organizes the findings along two parallel pathways converging on the psychological sustainability of the firm, operationalized in Section 2.6 as the balance between depletion (burnout, turnover intention), preservation (organizational trust, identification), and continuity (succession readiness) of psychological resources. On the family side, socioemotional wealth considerations, stewardship-consistent identification with the firm, and the structural permeability of the boundary between work and family roles jointly sustained family members’ continued commitment to the business, but at the cost of tolerating conflict, delaying succession, and absorbing spillover strain that remained largely invisible to outside observers. On the employee side, consistent with the bifurcation-bias mechanism, the same family closeness appeared to be read by non-family employees through a more agency-consistent lens attentive to fairness and monitoring, such that even modest asymmetries registered as nepotism and were associated with a disproportionate erosion of organizational trust. Both pathways converged on the same underlying resource: the psychological capital of the people who compose the firm, whether bound to it by kinship or by employment. In this case, family-side strain and employee-side fairness concerns co-occurred rather than substituting for one another, suggesting that succession planning and equitable, transparent practices toward non-family employees are best understood not as separate governance issues but as two faces of the same underlying challenge to a family firm’s psychological sustainability. These findings resonate with, and extend, recent case-based research on Italian family firms. Ferrari’s qualitative study similarly found that succession is frequently postponed rather than actively planned, driven by an ambivalent combination of incumbent reluctance and successor caution that mirrors the pattern observed in the present case [ 53 ]. On the employee side, Ferrari’s survey of SME employees found that perceived discrimination linked to nepotism was associated with reduced organizational commitment and a weakened sense of justice among non-family staff—a pattern consistent with, and considerably larger in scale than, the nepotism–trust association documented here, suggesting that the mechanism identified in this single case may generalize beyond it [ 54 ]. Marciánová et al. [ 55 ], using a multi-case methodology, similarly link nepotism directly to the long-term sustainability of family firms, reinforcing the interpretation, central to the present study, that nepotism-related dynamics are not a peripheral HR issue but a structural threat to a family firm’s psychological sustainability. 6. Conclusions This mixed-methods case study of a small Italian family-owned manufacturing firm shows that the psychological sustainability of family businesses depends on managing two only partly overlapping sources of strain: emotionally charged, spillover-prone relational dynamics among family members, and employees’ sensitivity to perceived fairness in how family and non-family resources are treated. 6.1. Limitations This study has several limitations related to its single-case design: findings are based on interviews with three family members and a survey of 26 employees from a single firm and should be read as context-specific analytic insights rather than as generalizable estimates. These findings should be read as offering analytic transferability [ 39 ]—insight that may inform understanding of conceptually similar cases—rather than statistical generalizability to family firms in general. With N = 26, the study had adequate power (>0.90) to detect the large effect observed for perceived nepotism, but was underpowered (power ≈ 0.32) to reliably detect medium-sized effects (r = 0.30); achieving 80% power for such effects would require approximately N = 85. Non-significant associations should therefore not be interpreted as evidence of absence of a relationship. Relatedly, gender and organizational tenure are reported in Appendix B only as descriptive correlates of the study variables and were not used as statistical controls (e.g., via partial correlation or regression): employees with markedly different tenure may well experience nepotism and its consequences differently, but testing this with the present sample would further reduce the degrees of freedom available and yield even less stable estimates. Controlling for tenure, supervisory role, and other individual differences is therefore identified as a priority for future research with an adequately powered sample, consistent with the power limitations noted above. A further limitation concerns common method bias: all employee-survey variables were collected via self-report from a single source at a single point in time, which can inflate correlations among constructs that share method variance [ 56 ]; this is a particular concern for the correlation between perceived nepotism and organizational trust reported above. A formal statistical test of common method variance, such as Harman’s single-factor test, was not conducted, as such tests are of limited reliability and are unlikely to be informative with a sample of N = 26, given their known sensitivity to sample size and reliance on assumptions unlikely to hold in small case-study samples. Procedurally, respondent anonymity was guaranteed and emphasized through the survey introduction, which may have reduced socially desirable responding; moreover, item order was randomized across constructs. Future research with larger samples would benefit from multi-source or multi-wave designs to more directly assess common method variance. Relatedly, despite the safeguards described in Section 3.5 , statistical anonymity within a firm of this size remains fragile [ 52 ]. The parental relationship to the case company of one of the authors is a further limitation to weigh alongside its methodological advantages: while it plausibly facilitated the candor visible in the interview excerpts and the initial access to the family, coding and thematic analysis were performed independently by researchers without any relationship to the case company specifically to limit this risk ( Section 3.5 ), though some influence on data collection and rapport cannot be fully ruled out; the quantitative survey of non-family employees, collected and analyzable independently of that relationship, was included as a further counterbalancing source of evidence. Future research should extend this design to multiple family firms across sectors and generational stages, ideally involving researchers without a personal relationship to the case, and could usefully incorporate longitudinal designs to capture how succession planning and perceived fairness evolve over time. Several of these limitations point directly to the specific directions for future research outlined in Section 6.3 , particularly the need for multi-case and longitudinal designs. 6.2. Practical Implications The findings suggest several concrete practices for family SMESs seeking to manage the psychological sustainability of both family and non-family stakeholders. Succession should be governed by explicit timelines and decision rights, rather than left as an informally anticipated but unplanned process, as observed in this case. Human resource practices should establish transparent, merit-based promotion criteria and performance-evaluation procedures visible to non-family staff, together with clear definition of family and non-family roles, since even low absolute levels of perceived nepotism were disproportionately corrosive to organizational trust in this sample. Structured conflict-resolution mechanisms, rather than the informal mediating role that emerged in this case, could reduce reliance on a single family member to manage intra-family tension. Finally, family firms could adopt explicit procedures for protecting employees from perceived favoritism, such as documented promotion criteria and dedicated channels for raising fairness concerns. 6.3. Future Research Future research should extend this design to multiple family firms across industries, countries, and generational stages, ideally involving researchers without a personal relationship to the case. Larger, adequately powered employee samples would allow multilevel designs comparing family and non-family employees. Longitudinal designs following succession processes over time, and multi-source measures of trust and performance (e.g., supervisor ratings alongside self-report), would address the cross-sectional and single-source limitations noted above. Future studies could also directly measure perceived bifurcation bias and psychological sustainability as constructs, rather than inferring them from the pattern of correlations observed here. Author Contributions Conceptualization, T.G. and C.C.; methodology, T.G. and M.C.; formal analysis, T.G. and M.S.; investigation, C.C.; writing—original draft preparation, T.G., C.C. and M.S.; writing—review and editing, T.G., M.S. and M.C.; supervision, T.G. and M.C. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript. Funding This research was funded by the Erasmus+ Programme of the European Union, Small-scale Partnership project "BEST” grant number 2024-1-IT01-KA210-VET-000249061. Institutional Review Board Statement The study was conducted in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki and approved by the Ethics Committee of the Department of Psychology, University “G. d’Annunzio” of Chieti–Pescara (approval code: n. 26014, approval date: 21 May 2026). Informed Consent Statement Informed consent was obtained from all subjects involved in the study. Data Availability Statement The data presented in this study are available on reasonable request from the corresponding author. The data are not publicly available due to confidentiality obligations toward a small, potentially identifiable organization and its employees. Acknowledgments Funded by the European Union. Views and opinions expressed are however those of the author(s) only and do not necessarily reflect those of the European Union or the Erasmus+ National Agency INAPP. Neither the European Union nor the granting authority can be held responsible for them. The authors thank the owning family and the employees of the case company for their availability and openness. Conflicts of Interest T.G., M.S., and M.C. have no relationship with the case company and declare no conflicts of interest. C.C. is a family member of the owning family of the case company, but is not an employee, shareholder, or manager of the firm and had no decision-making role in it at the time of data collection. This relationship is disclosed as a potential conflict of interest; see Section 3.5 for a discussion of how it was managed methodologically. Abbreviations The following abbreviations are used in this manuscript: SEW Socioemotional Wealth SME Small and Medium-sized Enterprise BAT-12 12-Item Burnout Assessment Tool SD Standard Deviation Appendix A Interview protocol administered to family members (translated from Italian). Please tell us the history of the firm: how it was founded, by whom, and how it developed over time. When did you become involved in the firm, and in what circumstances? What have been the most important challenges the firm has faced? Describe a moment when the firm’s continuity felt genuinely at risk. Is there an episode you consider particularly significant in the firm’s history? Why? How are decisions made in the firm? Who is involved in the process? Who has the final say on strategic choices? How was this role assigned? What do you think of this distribution of responsibility? Are there differences in how different generations work, manage, and make decisions? If so, describe an episode of tension or conflict; if not, why do you think there are no significant differences? What do you consider the firm’s fundamental values? How are these values transmitted across generations? How do you picture the firm’s future in terms of generational succession? Are there clear agreements on how to manage the transfer of responsibility? If so, what are they; if not, what makes such agreements difficult? Are there moments when work-related fatigue affects family dynamics? How do you cope with these moments? Have you ever wanted to step back from managing the firm? If so, what kept you from doing so? How would you describe the relationship between family members and non-family employees? Do you think the family nature of the firm affects how employees work? If so, how? Is there anything important that was not asked, but that you consider relevant to understanding the firm and your experience? Appendix B Table A1 reports the full Pearson correlation matrix among the survey scales, together with gender and organizational tenure, referenced in Section 4.2 . Variables are numbered as follows: 1 = Supervisor support; 2 = Coworker support; 3 = Perceived nepotism; 4 = Organizational trust; 5 = Organizational identification; 6 = Burnout; 7 = Turnover intention; 8 = Self-rated performance; 9 = Job satisfaction; 10 = Gender; 11 = Tenure. Note. Var. = variable number (see key above Table A1 ). Gender coded 1 = male, 2 = female. Only the association between perceived nepotism and organizational trust (Variables 3 and 4) was hypothesized a priori on theoretical grounds, following the bifurcation-bias literature ( Section 2.1 ); all other coefficients in this matrix are reported for descriptive and exploratory purposes only and should not be interpreted causally. Given the small sample size, coefficients |r| ≥ 0.39 correspond approximately to p < 0.05 and should be interpreted as exploratory indications of association rather than confirmatory tests. Rights: © 2026 by the authors. © 2026 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license. Edition changes: Licensed narrative text edition. Original headings, paragraphs and references are preserved with normalized whitespace and layout. Figures, tables, display equations and separately licensed third-party material are not reproduced; use the linked original full text for those elements and definitive pagination. This is an attributed republication, not newly conducted research.