Creative Commons source reading · Return-to-sport readiness
Return to Sport After Foot and Ankle Surgery Is Inconsistently Defined and Assessed: A Systematic Review
Konstantinos Oikonomou; Kush Savsani; Phillip Wyatt; John Cyrus; Brady Ernst; Albert T. Anastasio; Conor N. O’Neill; J. Brett Goodloe; Annunziato Amendola
Originally published in Arthrosc Sports Med Rehabil · 2026-10-29
From the article
Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.
Abstract
PurposeTo conduct a systematic review of return‐to‐sport (RTS) definitions in the orthopaedic literature, addressing common operative athletic foot and ankle pathologies including ankle instability, Achilles tendon ruptures or tendinopathy, and fifth metatarsal fractures.MethodsA systematic review was performed in adherence to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta‐Analyses guidelines. Cochrane, Embase, Medline, and CINAHL databases were searched for studies published through March 2024. Inclusion criteria were studies in which subjects were involved in some level of sports and received surgery for 1 of 3 common sports‐related injuries: ankle instability, Achilles tendinopathy, and fifth metatarsal fracture. The primary outcome was each study's definition of RTS.ResultsThere were 145 articles that met all…
DISCUSSION
The most important finding of this study was that most included articles (54.5%) failed to provide an explicit definition of RTS, with “undefined” methodologies being the most common assessment of RTS (44.1%). Among the remaining studies, the most common approach used objective events (26.2%), custom questionnaires (18.6%), and standardized PROMs (14.5%). The variability in RTS definitions displayed in this study is significant given its widespread use in orthopaedic literature, its influence on athlete expectations, and its role in clinical decision‐making. Clearly defining RTS enhances study clarity and allows for more effective comparison across studies. However, only a minority of studies provided explicit RTS definitions, and considerable variability existed among them. For example, Robbins et al. defined RTS as “having played in…
CONCLUSIONS
Most articles included in this systematic review did not provide an explicit definition of RTS or a clearly defined assessment methodology. When specified, RTS was assessed using objective events, custom questionnaires, or standardized PROMs, highlighting substantial heterogeneity in both RTS definitions and assessment approaches across foot and ankle literature.
Editorial reading guide
- How were injury, recovery and exposure defined and verified?
- Which criteria support progression, and what finding should stop or change the plan?
