Creative Commons source reading · Musculoskeletal and tissue health
No Difference in Return-to-Sport Rate or Activity Level in People with Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) Injury Managed with ACL Reconstruction or Rehabilitation Alone: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Stephanie R. Filbay; Garrett Bullock; Scott Russell; Frances Brown; Wilson Hui; Thorlene Egerton
Originally published in Sports Med · 2025-07-02
From the article
Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.
Abstract
BackgroundA common belief amongst patients and clinicians is that anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction is required to return to sport. It is not clear if this belief is supported by the best available research.ObjectiveWe aimed to compare return-to-sport and activity levels following anterior cruciate ligament rupture managed with anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction versus rehabilitation alone.MethodsWe performed a systematic review and meta-analysis. A comprehensive search was conducted across seven electronic databases for empirical studies published to July 2023. Articles were included if they assessed return-to-sport and/or activity levels in two groups where one underwent an anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction and the other had exercise-based rehabilitation that was standardised and/or supervised by a healthcare…
Confidence in Review Findings
The level of certainty in the review findings was determined based on the GRADE (Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluations) criteria [29]. Level of certainty could be downgraded because of the risk of bias, inconsistency of findings, indirectness of source studies and/or imprecision of findings; or upgraded owing to a large effect, and/or if confounding variables or known study biases were likely to reduce a demonstrated effect [29].
Discussion
This systematic review found no difference in return-to-sport or activity levels when people with ACL injury were managed with ACLR compared to rehabilitation alone. The certainty of this evidence was very low, mainly owing to the study designs predominantly having a high risk of bias. However, the bias due to confounders related to baseline differences and/or differences in the activity and return-to-sport advice given between groups was more likely to favour the ACLR groups and disadvantage the rehabilitation-alone groups. Specifically, ten of the 15 included studies either recommended non-surgical management if patients were less active pre-injury or did not plan to return to sport and/or only advised people in the non-surgical group that they should not return to sport. In many of the studies, ACLR was encouraged for those who…
Editorial reading guide
- How were injury, recovery and exposure defined and verified?
- Which criteria support progression, and what finding should stop or change the plan?
