Creative Commons source reading · Musculoskeletal and tissue health
A Narrative Review of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction Graft Choice and Its Influence on Return to Sport
Garrett R. Jackson; Justin T. Childers; Colton C. Mowers; Jaxon S. Boley; Patrick Ryan; Steven F. DeFroda; Clayton Nuelle
Originally published in Curr Rev Musculoskelet Med · 2026-10-21
From the article
Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.
Abstract
Purpose of ReviewAnterior cruciate ligament (ACL) rupture is among the most common knee injuries in active individuals and can lead to persistent instability, secondary intra-articular damage, and an elevated risk of osteoarthritis. Because return to sport (RTS) is a major goal for most active patients and graft selection remains one of the most debated aspects of ACL reconstruction, this narrative review summarizes the contemporary evidence on how graft choice influences RTS, focusing on the four most common grafts: bone–patellar tendon–bone (BTB), hamstring tendon (HT), quadriceps tendon (QT), and allograft.Recent FindingsRTS rates range from ~ 65% to 73% at three years and are higher (83–90%) in elite and high-school athletes. In young, active patients, autografts are associated with higher RTS and lower revision rates than…
Conclusions
When RTS is considered a primary outcome, the available literature supports the use of autograft tissue over allograft in young and active patients. However, current high-quality evidence does not demonstrate consistent superiority of one autograft option over another with respect to RTS rates alone. BTB grafts offer reliable bone-to-bone healing and low revision rates, HT grafts provide less donor-site morbidity and less anterior knee pain, and QT grafts have emerged as a versatile option with favorable biomechanical properties and encouraging clinical outcomes. Therefore, graft selection should be individualized according to patient age, sport, activity level, anatomic considerations, and risk of reinjury. For high-demand athletes, the authors generally favor QT or BTB autografts because of their predictable graft characteristics…
Editorial reading guide
- How were injury, recovery and exposure defined and verified?
- Which criteria support progression, and what finding should stop or change the plan?
