Creative Commons source reading · Musculoskeletal and tissue health
Is there a correlation between levels of incapability and athletic identity?
Alexander Drost; Jakob Bleacher; David Ring; Amin Razi; Jefferson Hunter; Aydin Azarpey
Originally published in PLoS One · 2026-09-30
From the article
Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.
Abstract
ObjectivesAmong people seeking sports-specific musculoskeletal specialty care we sought to determine 1) whether level of athletic identity mediates or moderates the relationship between thoughts and feelings and levels of capability and pain intensity, and 2) whether levels of pain intensity and capability differ among statistical groupings based on age and mindsets including athletic identity.MethodsAdult patients seeing a sports medicine specialist (n = 135) completed measures of levels of capability, pain intensity, thoughts and feelings regarding sensation, and identification as an athlete. We planned mediation/moderation analysis. When that was not feasible, weadded an unplanned, exploratory cluster analysis of mindset factors.ResultsThe lack of correlation between athletic identity and levels of capability and pain intensity…
Discussion
Stronger athletic identities are associated with higher levels of self-esteem and confidence, enhanced athletic performance, and better social relations [10]. And perceived or actual loss of a relatively strong athletic identity is associated with greater symptoms of depression during recovery from injury [10]. Evidence that levels of athletic identity mediate or moderate the relationship between thoughts and feelings about sensations and levels of discomfort and incapability has the potential to inform more effective strategies for athlete health and performance. Absence of mediation and moderation effects might suggest that athletic identities are not more impactful than other identities on the important relationship between mindsets and health. In a cross-sectional study of people seeking musculoskeletal specialty care from a…
Conclusion
The finding of no direct association between athletic identity and pain intensity or capability alongside notable associations with less healthy thoughts and feelings--many of which address threats to cherished roles and identities--suggests that athletic identity, and perhaps other identities are less important than the perceived threat to one’s self-identity in general. The exploratory cluster analysis supports the hypothesis that distress, rather than athletic identity, could be a more important correlate of pain intensity. Many musculoskeletal pathophysiologies are permanent, senescent or post-traumatic pathophysiologies in particular. But an evolution in one’s narrative identity is always available. Adapting one’s identity to match pathophysiology and impairment--healthy thoughts and feelings regarding bodily sensations---is good…
Editorial reading guide
- How were injury, recovery and exposure defined and verified?
- Which criteria support progression, and what finding should stop or change the plan?
