Journal DOI 10.68956/journal.human-performance-futures

Creative Commons source reading · Return-to-sport readiness

Sport-Specific Considerations in ACL Reconstruction: Diagnostic Evaluation and Graft Selection

Assala Abu Mukh; Giacomo Placella; Ki-Mo Jang

Originally published in Diagnostics (Basel) · 2026-02-15

From the article

Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.

Abstract

Knee biomechanical demands vary across different sports due to sport- and position-specific patterns of muscle recruitment. To return to performance, athletes must adequately restore knee kinematics to regain control over the same sport mechanics that led to the initial anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury. ACL graft selection should therefore minimize donor site morbidity and support sport-specific demands. This study aims to address the available evidence and guide surgical graft choice in athletes. A literature search of PubMed, MEDLINE, Scopus, and Web of Science (up to September 2025) assessed BPTB, hamstring, and quadriceps tendon autografts. Outcomes included revision, graft survival, return to sport, time to return, PROMs, anterior knee pain, donor site morbidity, and prognostic factors (age, sex). Sports were classified as…

5. Discussion

When considering RTS, TTRS, and PROMs, all autograft options appear to provide comparable results. Therefore, revision rates and donor site morbidities become the key outcome parameters to balance when selecting the graft and should integrate patient-specific factors with an understanding of sport-specific biomechanical demands [48,57]. In pivoting and cutting sports, abrupt directional changes, deceleration, and landing represent high-risk mechanics. Thus, regardless of graft choice, sport-specific injury prevention programs should target these movements. BPTB autografts appear to offer both high survival rates and high complication rates, making them a suitable option for young female pivoters [32,33]. However, the relatively high incidence of anterior knee pain is a considerable drawback, particularly for sports that require…

6. Conclusions

Graft selection for ACL reconstruction in athletes should be individualized according to sport-specific biomechanical demands rather than based on a uniform strategy. While BPTB, HT, and QT autografts yield comparable RTS rates and PROMs, differences in revision risk and donor site morbidity remain clinically relevant. In pivoting and cutting sports, BPTB grafts provide reliable stability but are frequently associated with anterior knee pain, whereas HT grafts offer lower donor site morbidity with a higher susceptibility to revision in younger and high-risk athletes. In contact and collision sports, graft durability must be balanced against functional morbidity, making adequately sized HT or QT grafts reasonable alternatives. For endurance and non-pivoting athletes, HT grafts appear most suitable due to preserved muscle symmetry and…

Editorial reading guide

  • How were injury, recovery and exposure defined and verified?
  • Which criteria support progression, and what finding should stop or change the plan?