Journal DOI 10.68956/journal.human-performance-futures

Creative Commons source reading · Return-to-sport readiness

Patients 40 Years of Age or Older Have Comparable Return to Sport Rates, Reinjury Rates, and 2‐Year Patient‐Reported Outcomes After Medial or Lateral Meniscus Repair Compared With Patients Younger Than 40 Years of Age

Alexander E. White; Tyler J. Uppstrom; Akshay K. Raghuram; Thun Itthipanichpong; Samarth V. Menta; Robert B. Baldwin; Shu‐Han Wang; Anil S. Ranawat

Originally published in Arthrosc Sports Med Rehabil · 2026-09-06

From the article

Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.

Abstract

PurposeTo compare patient‐reported outcomes, return to sport (RTS), and reinjury rates after meniscus repair in patients over and under the age of 40 years old.MethodsMeniscus repair cases performed at a single tertiary care center between December 2010 and August 2021 with a minimum 2‐year follow‐up data were reviewed. Patient‐reported outcome measures, RTS, and reinjury data were obtained from an institutional knee registry and prospective surveys. Patients were classified as (1) <40 years old with isolated meniscus repair, (2) ≥40 years old with isolated meniscus repair, (3) <40 years old with meniscus repair and anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, and (4) ≥40 years old with meniscus repair and anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction.ResultsOne hundred thirty patients were included, 91 were <40 years old and 39 were ≥40…

RESULTS

There were 130 patients (56% men) included in the final analysis. The mean patient age was 33.6 years old (±10.65), and the mean body mass index was 25.19 (±4.18). Of these patients, 91 (70%) were less than 40 years old and 39 (30%) were greater than or equal to 40 years old. There were 86 patients (66.2%) who underwent medial meniscus repair, 35 patients (26.9%) who underwent lateral meniscus repair, and 9 patients (6.92%) who underwent both medial and lateral meniscus repairs. One hundred nine (83.9%) of the meniscus tears were described as vertical, 7 (5.4%) were bucket handle tears, and 14 patients (10.8%) had both vertical and bucket handle tears. The tear location was at the posterior horn in 85 patients (66.4%), the posterior horn and body in 31 patients (24.2%), posterior horn, body, and anterior horn in 5 patients (3.9%),…

DISCUSSION

In this study, we found that meniscus repair can be performed successfully in patients over the age of 40 who have an amenable tear type. Meniscus repair was performed almost exclusively in patients with good tissue quality (no plastic deformation) who have tears that occur in the red‐red or red‐white zones. There were rare exceptions where tears in the white‐white zone were repaired because a partial meniscectomy would have resulted in greater than 70% of the meniscus being removed. There were no differences in RTS rates or meniscus repair failure rates when comparing patients who were younger than 40 to those who were 40 or older. Although Marx activity scores were significantly lower for the 40 or older group, the remainder of PROMs did not differ between age groups postoperatively. All of these findings are upheld in the setting…

Editorial reading guide

  • How were injury, recovery and exposure defined and verified?
  • Which criteria support progression, and what finding should stop or change the plan?