Creative Commons source reading · Musculoskeletal and tissue health
Postoperative Quadriceps Symmetry, Knee Laxity, and Single-Leg Hop Performance in Association with 24-Month Ipsilateral Graft Retear After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: A Cohort Study
Kakavas G; Malliaropoulos N; Forelli F
Originally published in Life (Basel) · 2026-09-16
From the article
Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.
Abstract
AbstractBackground: Ipsilateral graft retear after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) remains a major concern in athletes, while the relationship between postoperative mechanical and functional measures and retear remains uncertain. Methods: This cohort study included 48 athletes after primary unilateral ACLR with hamstring-tendon autograft. Follow-up was scheduled at 6, 9, and 12 months (184 ± 13, 276 ± 17, and 368 ± 22 days), and the analytic export retained one postoperative value per athlete for GNRB side-to-side laxity at 250 N, concentric isokinetic quadriceps limb symmetry index (LSI) at 60°/s, single-leg hop-for-distance LSI, and patient-reported outcomes, without preserving the originating visit. MRI-confirmed ipsilateral graft retear was recorded within 24 months after clinically suspected reinjury; retear…
4. Discussion
The principal finding was that quadriceps limb symmetry showed the clearest association with ipsilateral graft retear within 24 months, whereas GNRB side-to-side laxity, single-leg hop-for-distance symmetry, IKDC, KOOS-Sport, and ACL-RSI did not show statistically robust univariable associations and their confidence intervals were generally wide. Athletes with retear had a quadriceps LSI 6.9 percentage points lower than those without retear, and the observed retear proportion was higher when quadriceps LSI was <85%; this threshold comparison was exploratory and cohort-specific. In the exploratory penalized model, greater quadriceps symmetry remained associated with lower retear odds. The apparent AUC was 0.84 and decreased to approximately 0.78 after bootstrap optimism correction; with only 14 events, this represents exploratory…
5. Conclusions
Within this exploratory 48-athlete cohort, postoperative quadriceps limb symmetry showed the clearest association with 24-month ipsilateral ACL graft-retear status, but temporal precedence between the retained measurement and retear could not be established. Single-leg hop-for-distance asymmetry showed a clinically relevant but statistically imprecise pattern, while neither continuous GNRB SSD measured at 250 N nor the prespecified SSD thresholds showed a clear association with retear. Patient-reported outcomes also showed no statistically robust association with retear in this sample. These findings support multidimensional RTS assessment with particular attention to quadriceps recovery, but the exploratory <85% LSI finding is cohort-specific and does not establish a validated return-to-sport threshold or stand-alone clearance criterion.
Editorial reading guide
- How were injury, recovery and exposure defined and verified?
- Which criteria support progression, and what finding should stop or change the plan?
