Journal DOI 10.68956/journal.human-performance-futures

Creative Commons source reading · Youth and adolescent athletes

Sport specialization predicts athletic identity exclusivity in youth athletes: a three-wave RI-CLPM study of controlling coaching and non-sport peer restriction with implications for adolescent care

Xishan Liu; Hao Liu; Feng Shao; Dongdong Ma

Originally published in Front Psychol · 2026-09-18

From the article

Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.

Abstract

BackgroundSport specialization has usually been examined through biomedical outcomes such as overuse injury, burnout, and premature dropout. Less is known about whether specialization is prospectively associated with adolescent identity development by narrowing opportunities for exploration beyond sport. Drawing on identity status theory, self-determination theory, and bioecological systems theory, this study examined whether sport specialization intensity predicts athletic identity exclusivity among youth athletes and whether longitudinal indirect pathways involve controlling coach behaviors and non-sport peer restriction.MethodsA three-wave longitudinal design was implemented across a six-month period. Participants were 542 adolescent athletes (mean age = 14.63 years, SD = 1.48; 53.5% male) recruited from youth sport academies,…

Overview of principal findings

This study examined whether sport specialization intensity predicts athletic identity exclusivity in youth athletes and whether this association operates through controlling coach behaviors and non-sport peer restriction. Using a three-wave longitudinal design and an RI-CLPM, the study provides within-person evidence for a developmental process that has been theoretically plausible but empirically underexamined. When athletes became more specialized relative to their own expected level, they subsequently reported greater identity exclusivity. Significant longitudinal indirect associations were observed through increases in controlling coach behaviors and non-sport peer restriction. In addition, controlling coaching predicted later specialization, suggesting that specialized sport participation and controlling interpersonal climates…

Practical implications for youth sport

The findings have practical implications for youth sport policy. Recommendations to delay specialization and encourage diversified participation have often been justified on physical and performance grounds (Côté et al., 2009; Côté and Vierimaa, 2014; LaPrade et al., 2016). The present results suggest that these recommendations are also relevant to identity development. Because greater specialization intensity prospectively predicted identity exclusivity, sport organizations should consider monitoring training loads, safeguarding off-season periods, and ensuring athletes have structural opportunities for non-sport exploration. However, policy alone is unlikely to be sufficient. Some athletes may specialize later but still experience controlling coaching and peer restriction. Therefore, sport systems should address both the structure…

Editorial reading guide

  • Whose development is represented, and who may be excluded by the sampling or pathway?
  • Which outcome reflects durable learning or development rather than short-term selection?