Creative Commons source reading · Talent development systems
Annual Athlete Turnover of 36% in Olympic Talent Promotion Programs: A Meta-analysis
Güllich A; Barth M
Originally published in Sports Med Open · 2026-06-30
From the article
Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.
Abstract
AbstractBackgroundAcross the world, many national sport systems make extensive strategic investments in talent promotion programs (TPPs). The most common TPPs include youth sport academies and sport federations’ junior squads. The central idea of TPPs is (1) to select the most promising talents at young ages (around puberty or younger) and (2) to involve them in a long-term continuous nurturing process to facilitate their performance development, eventually leading to increased senior peak performance. This central idea implies that the population of TPP participants is highly stable across age categories. On the other hand, TPPs sometimes replace deselected athletes with new ‘side-entry’ athletes (athletes who enter a TPP after its initial age category). Hence, there is athlete turnover—fluctuation in the TPP population through exits…
Results
The mean annual athlete turnover within TPPs is 36.3% (Table 2).6 It is slightly higher in federations’ junior squads than youth sport academies (Wald χ2 = 4.274, p = 0.039). The athlete turnover does not differ significantly across age categories (Wald χ2 = 1.308, p = 0.520), sexes (Wald χ2 = 0.902, p = 0.342), or between older and recent studies (Wald χ2 = 0.552, p = 0.458, Table 2). The dataset does not enable sport-specific comparisons. Yet, annual athlete turnover does not differ significantly between the largest sport-specific subsample, soccer, and the other Olympic sports (36.4%, 95% CI 32.3%–40.5%, vs 36.0%, 95% CI 28.9%–43.1%, Wald χ2 = 0.013, p = 0.911). All primary studies had a high methodological quality and the risk of bias was generally low (see Table S3). The funnel plot shows a slightly skewed distribution and…
Discussion
The foundational idea of TPPs suggests that talents are identified and selected at young ages—often around puberty or younger—and are then involved in a long-term continuous TPP nurturing process until senior peak performance. This meta-analysis investigated the extent to which the operating principle of TPPs corresponds to their foundational idea. The central finding is that the factual operating principle of the TPP system is different than its original idea. In contrast to its central idea, the evidence suggests that the operating principle of the TPP system is characterized by significant annual athlete turnover, reflecting frequent selection, deselection, and replacement of youth athletes across age categories. The meta-analysis included studies of athletes from all Olympic sports and 42 countries, and the evidence is robust…
Editorial reading guide
- Whose development is represented, and who may be excluded by the sampling or pathway?
- Which outcome reflects durable learning or development rather than short-term selection?
