Creative Commons source reading · Coaching and pedagogy
Coaching effectiveness in competitive youth contact sports and martial arts: athletes’ and coaches’ perceptions
Müjdeci İ; Kılıç K; Bulut A; Kuru H
Originally published in Front Psychol · 2026-01-09
From the article
Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.
Abstract
AbstractBackgroundContact sports and martial arts can provide an avenue for young athletes’ development in physical and psychosocial aspects. Athletes’ consistent development of competence, confidence, connection, and character (the 4 Cs) are the desired athlete outcomes for optimal development in a defined sport context, reflecting the extent of coaching effectiveness and the quality of youth sport programming. The purpose of this study was to assess athletes’ 4 Cs with respect to their age, gender, competitive level, and birthdate.MethodsAthletes (n = 454; 12–18 years of age) and their coaches (n = 45) from boxing, judo, karate, kickboxing, taekwondo, and wrestling completed validated measures of the 4Cs of athlete development. Analyses were conducted for each sport outcome separately to examine differences in athletes’ responses. A…
Results
Examination of the descriptive account of the athletes’ responses revealed a general high outcome score in each of the 4 Cs. (Table 3). All of the athletes’ perceived outcomes fell within the upper quartile of their respective ranges. The athletes’ 4 Cs scores, categorized by age groups (12–14 and 15–18) and gender, would be analyzed using independent sample t-tests. On the other hand, 4 Cs scores in terms of competitive level, and birthdate quartiles would be analyzed with one-way ANOVA. Furthermore, post hoc analyses were performed on all statistically significant ANOVA tests, and Bonferroni test results were interpreted. The results of the comparisons are reported separately below. Age group comparisons of the athletes’ 4 Cs revealed that there were no significant differences in the athletes’ character and confidence scores between…
Discussion
One practical way to evaluating coaching effectiveness is to investigate athletes’ desired developmental sport outcomes from their own perspectives (Erickson et al., 2024). Drawing on the 4 Cs model (Côté and Gilbert, 2009), the current study examined the four domains of development in competitive youth contact sports among the athletes. Specifically, the athletes’ perceptions of competence, confidence, connection, and character, and whether their scores differ in each of them by their age, gender, competitive level, and birthdate were examined. In the following paragraphs, we discuss the implications of the findings with the extant literature, which we believe is relevant to coaching practice, coach development policies, and future research for young athletes’ holistic development in sport. Researchers suggest that positive…
Editorial reading guide
- Whose development is represented, and who may be excluded by the sampling or pathway?
- Which outcome reflects durable learning or development rather than short-term selection?
