Journal DOI 10.68956/journal.human-performance-futures

Creative Commons source reading · Talent development systems

Assessing fundamental motor skills proficiency in school-based sports physical education programs: implications for talent development

Hubert Makaruk; E. Kipling Webster; Jared Porter; Beata Makaruk; Anna Bodasińska; Janusz Zieliński; Paweł Tomaszewski; Marta Nogal; Marcin Starzak; Marcin Śliwa; Michał Banaś; Michał Biegajło; Agata Chaliburda; Bogusz Suchecki; Bartosz Molik; Jerzy Sadowski

Originally published in Front Sports Act Living · 2025-08-21

From the article

Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.

Abstract

IntroductionFundamental motor skills (FMS) are essential for fostering physical literacy, supporting talent development, and promoting public health in school-aged populations. This study aimed to evaluate FMS proficiency among students in school-based sports physical education (PE) programs, which offer sport-specific training, and compare it to students in traditional PE programs. A secondary aim was to examine whether these programs promote early specialization or early diversification in youth sport development.MethodsA cross-sectional analysis was conducted on 1,332 students (ages 10–14; 58% boys) from 12 schools across Poland, including 547 students in school-based sports PE programs and 785 in traditional PE. The Fundamental Motor Skills in Sport (FUS) test, a qualitative and process-oriented assessment tool, was used to…

Results

Table 1 presents the distribution of overall FMS proficiency levels by sex and PE program type. In the school-based sports PE group, the majority of students demonstrated “insufficient FMS proficiency” (boys: 71.7%; girls: 77.2%), yet these rates were significantly lower than those observed in traditional PE (boys: 89.6%; girls: 91.8%; χ² = 41.0 for boys and 23.8 for girls, both p < 0.001). The corresponding effect sizes (Cramer's V = 0.23 for boys, 0.17 for girls) indicate small associations between program type and proficiency levels, showing clear distributional differences despite some overlap. Although only a small proportion of students in sport PE programs achieved an “excellent” level of FMS proficiency, these programs were associated with a noticeably greater representation in the “good” category (boys: 12.6%; girls: 5.6%; χ²…

Discussion

This study assessed the FMS proficiency of students in school-based sports PE programs and examined whether these programs align more closely with early specialization or diversification models. The findings highlight a critical concern: although students in sport-focused PE programs performed significantly better than their peers in traditional PE, the overall proficiency in these programs remained alarmingly low. Approximately 72% of boys and 77% of girls in sport-specialized PE programs failed to reach even an “elementary” level of FMS proficiency, highlighting substantial gaps in motor competence development despite their participation in structured, sport-specific training. Furthermore, the data revealed that these programs predominantly emphasize sport-specific skills at the expense of overall FMS proficiency, a structural…

Editorial reading guide

  • Whose development is represented, and who may be excluded by the sampling or pathway?
  • Which outcome reflects durable learning or development rather than short-term selection?