Creative Commons source reading · Coaching and pedagogy
Sustaining mental toughness under controlling coaching: a moderated mediation model of the coach–athlete relationship and resilience in elite collegiate sports
Kim I; Kim S
Originally published in Front Psychol · 2026-06-16
From the article
Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.
Abstract
AbstractIntroductionThe psychological resilience of elite athletes is often tested by the interpersonal climate established by their coaches. This study aimed to delineate the integrated psychological pathways through which controlling coaching behaviors undermine an athlete’s mental toughness, specifically exploring the interplay between the coach–athlete relationship (CAR) and individual resilience.MethodsWe analyzed data from a sample of 206 elite male university soccer players in South Korea. The hypothesized moderated mediation model was empirically tested using Hayes’ PROCESS macro (Model 15) with a 5,000-sample bootstrap procedure. Structural validity and common method bias were rigorously assessed prior to the main analysis.ResultsPath analysis revealed that while the direct impact of controlling coaching on mental toughness…
Discussion
The primary objective of this study was to examine an integrated moderated mediation model to delineate how perceived controlling coaching, the coach–athlete relationship, and individual resilience collectively relate to the mental toughness of elite collegiate soccer players. The results provide nuanced evidence that while environmental stressors associated with the “dark side” of coaching are linked to diminished psychological fortitude, individual adaptive resources serve as a critical boundary condition that can neutralize these negative associations.
Practical implications and limitations
While the present findings provide critical insights into the protective mechanisms of resilience, several methodological constraints must be acknowledged. First, the cross-sectional design of this study precludes the establishment of strict causal inferences. Although the moderated mediation model was grounded in robust theoretical frameworks such as SDT and Interdependence Theory, the observed associations represent a single temporal snapshot. Future research should utilize longitudinal or diary-study designs to capture the dynamic fluctuations in coaching behaviors and athlete responses over a competitive season, thereby elucidating the long-term cumulative impact of controlling environments on psychological growth. Furthermore, the reliance on self-report measures introduces the possibility of common-method bias; integrating…
Editorial reading guide
- Whose development is represented, and who may be excluded by the sampling or pathway?
- Which outcome reflects durable learning or development rather than short-term selection?
