Journal DOI 10.68956/journal.human-performance-futures

Creative Commons source reading · Women and female-athlete health

Why We Must Stop Assuming and Estimating Menstrual Cycle Phases in Laboratory and Field-Based Sport Related Research

Elliott-Sale KJ; Altini M; Doyle-Baker P; Ferrer E; Flood TR; Harris R; Impellizzeri FM; de Jonge XJ; Kryger KO; Lewin G; Lebrun CM; McCall A; Nimphius S; Phillips SM; Swinton PA; Taylor M; Verhagen E; Burden RJ

Originally published in Sports Med · 2025-03-14

From the article

Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.

Abstract

AbstractThe increased growth, popularity, and media interest in women’s sport has led to calls for greater prioritisation of female-specific research and innovation. In response, science and medicine researchers have increased the volume of sport-related studies investigating female-specific matters, such as the menstrual cycle. Whilst the accelerated rate of published studies with female participants is welcome, the emerging trend of using assumed or estimated menstrual cycle phases to characterise ovarian hormone profiles is a significant concern. Replacing direct measurements of key characteristics of the menstrual cycle (e.g. the surge in luteinising hormone prior to ovulation via urine detection and sufficient luteal phase progesterone via blood or saliva sampling) with assumptions or estimates (i.e. no measurements) is proposed…

Conclusion

Assumed or estimated menstrual cycle phases are an unreasonable approach in research studies. When only menstruation is tracked, the menstrual cycle can only be divided into menstruation and non-menstruation days. At a minimum, ovulation needs to be confirmed and biochemical luteal phase deficiency excluded to establish menstrual cycle phases, which are based on significant changes in ovarian hormone concentrations. Given the issues associated with assumed or estimated phases described herein, we suggest that researchers, amongst others (e.g. reviewers, editors, the media), consider the individual and cumulative value of these studies on women’s sport, and either reject these methods, or at the very least use transparent and honest reporting about inadequacies of approaches taken. We encourage researchers to reflect upon the issues…

Editorial reading guide

  • Was the study designed for the population to which its conclusion is applied?
  • What safeguard, access need or equity consequence should shape implementation?