Journal DOI 10.68956/journal.human-performance-futures

Creative Commons source reading · Safeguarding and athlete safety

Italian Guidelines for Cardiological Evaluation in Competitive Football Players: A Detailed Review of COCIS Protocols

Longo UG; Ahlbaumer G; Vannicelli R; Gregorace E; Ortolina D; Nicodemi G; Altieri D; Carnevale A; Carucci S; Colella A; Scalfaro F; Lemme E

Originally published in Healthcare (Basel) · 2025-08-07

From the article

Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.

Abstract

AbstractBackground: Medical clearance for competitive sports is vital to safeguarding athletes’ health, particularly in high-intensity disciplines like football. In Italy, fitness assessments follow stringent protocols set by the Commissione di Vigilanza per il controllo dell’Idoneità Sportiva (COCIS), with a strong focus on cardiovascular screening. The primary goal is to prevent sudden cardiac death (SCD), a rare but catastrophic event in athletes. Methods: This paper provides an in-depth narrative review of the 2023 COCIS guidelines, examining the cardiological screening process, required diagnostic tests, management of identified cardiovascular conditions, and the protocols’ role in reducing SCD risk. Results: Comparisons with international standards underscore the effectiveness of the Italian approach. Conclusions: The COCIS 2023…

6. Discussion

The implementation of the COCIS protocols could prompt considerations regarding their practicality, cost-effectiveness, and psychological impact on athletes. One concern revolves around the financial implications of mandatory comprehensive screenings, particularly the routine use of ECGs and advanced diagnostic tests. The expenses associated with widespread ECG screening, especially in countries with large athlete populations or constrained healthcare budgets, may be prohibitive [24]. The costs of additional testing resulting from false-positive results could strain resources and may not be justifiable given the relatively low incidence of SCD. However, extensive research supports the cost-effectiveness of such screenings in the long term. A study published in 2010 by Wheeler et al. [23] demonstrated that pre-participation…

7. Conclusions

The Italian COCIS protocols for cardiological clearance in competitive football offer a structured model for preventing sudden cardiac death (SCD) in athletes [4]. Through mandatory ECG-based screening and follow-up evaluations, COCIS demonstrates how systematic and proactive prevention can significantly reduce risk, highlighted by an 89% drop in SCD incidence among Italian athletes between 1979–1980 and 2003–2004 [15,40]. As other countries consider similar strategies, the Italian experience underscores the need to balance screening efficacy with the minimization of false positives [28]. Future directions include longitudinal outcome studies, international validation of screening criteria, and the integration of genomic tools for improved risk stratification. Ultimately, the evolving COCIS framework remains centered on athlete…

Editorial reading guide

  • Was the study designed for the population to which its conclusion is applied?
  • What safeguard, access need or equity consequence should shape implementation?