Creative Commons source reading · Para and adaptive sport
Adaptive sport as affirmation: “We focus on our strengths, not our disabilities”
Norah Anita Schwartz; Christine Alysse von Glascoe
Originally published in PLoS One · 2023-05-10
From the article
Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.
Abstract
This paper offers a counter-narrative to the stereotype of people with physical and cognitive impairments being less inclined to participate in athletic activities. It contributes to the affirmative model proposed by Swain and French, which posits a non-tragic view of disability that encompasses positive social identities. We employed the tools of ethnography and phenomenology to explore the adaptive athlete experience among individuals practicing various sports and exhibiting divergent levels of proficiency. Findings confirm the appropriateness of the affirmative model and provide examples of movement from the state of liminality to that of communitas as defined by Victor Turner.
Discussion: “Focus on our strengths”
Phenomenologists such as Maurice Merleau-Ponty and Edmund Husserl study the lived experience of the body; specifically, what it is like to be in one’s body, and of one’s body [51–54]. Being in one’s body as an athlete requires, if nothing else, concentration. When rock climbing, unless I am willing to fall, I leave no room in my conscious thought process for anything other than reaching that next hold. When swimming, I count my breaths. I am conscious when in the ocean that I am not in control of the space shared with creatures larger, and probably hungrier, than myself. If I am intent on making it back to shore, it is on my strokes—on my strengths—that I must focus. Even more so if I am to reach my goal of climbing Yosemite’s 3200 foot monolith, El Capitan, as one of the few women with a disability (Fig 4). Through the lens of…
Conclusion
This exploratory ethnography addressed some of the common misconceptions and stereotypes about athletes with dis/abilities. In it, we applied Swain and French’s (2000) affirmative model, which posits a non-tragic view of disability, as well as Turner’s [2] theories on liminality and communitas. We present some of the voices of a new generation of people living with impairment, born into a world where others who came before fought for the early elements of what has come to be known as universal design, and who fought against stereotypes and limits imposed by society and its institutions. This generation is not deterred from living a fully realized life that can include recognition both at the table and on the podium.
Editorial reading guide
- Was the study designed for the population to which its conclusion is applied?
- What safeguard, access need or equity consequence should shape implementation?
