Creative Commons source reading · Women and female-athlete health
Preliminary Evaluation of Self-Reported Training Volume as an Adjunct Measure of Female Athlete Triad Risk in Division 1 Collegiate Female Runners
Sarah Parnell; Austin J. Graybeal; Megan E. Renna; Jon Stavres
Originally published in J Funct Morphol Kinesiol · 2024-09-27
From the article
Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.
Abstract
Background/Objectives: This study tested whether self-reported training volume is predictive of female athlete triad risk collected using an established twelve-question triad screening tool in National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) Division I (DI) collegiate female runners. Methods: A total of 319 institutions were initially contacted, seven of which agreed to distribute surveys to their female cross-country and track and field athletes. A total of 41 of 149 respondents completed the survey and met all inclusion criteria. Linear and binomial logistic regressions examined the relationships between self-reported training volumes and estimated triad risk. Independent samples t-tests were also used to compare training volumes across the high (> 50th percentile for risk factor counts) vs. low-risk groups. Results: Total weekly…
4. Discussion
Often undetected, the triad is a perilous syndrome known for impacting women of all athletic levels and is therefore screened by most programs before allowing active sports participation [2]. However, there is still much that needs to be uncovered regarding the triad and its development in trained female athletes. Knowing the triad has several screening protocols already in place, such as the 12 questions from the 2016 Coalition triad screening survey [2], this study sought to determine whether self-reported measures of training volume would be associated with self-reported indices of triad risk in female collegiate track and field athletes. Several measures of self-reported training volume were significantly associated with or predictive of self-reported triad risk. Total weekly resistance training for the competition and…
4.3. Implications for Survey-Based Training Volume as Predictor of Triad Risk
Although more accessible on a broader scale, survey-based triad risk has some inherent limitations that may limit the identification of triad risk in collegiate female athletes. A notable issue in a remote survey-based study is honesty in self-reporting, especially if the distribution of the surveys is in an online, remote fashion where no physical accountability is held for the participants [29]. Even in anonymous surveys, biased perceptions of oneself such as with personal eating and training habits or a fear of divulging information detrimental to social or sporting appearance have the potential to undermine honest responses to these sensitive questions. Faulty recall can additionally weaken accuracy, especially with questions regarding training volume measures and triad risk factors, and certain questions addressing bone health…
Editorial reading guide
- Was the study designed for the population to which its conclusion is applied?
- What safeguard, access need or equity consequence should shape implementation?
