Creative Commons source reading · Team and collective performance
Collective narcissism, stadium atmosphere, and schadenfreude: predictors of dysfunctional fan behavior
Ebru Güzel Kuyucu; Nurettin Göksu Çini
Originally published in Front Psychol · 2026-07-29
From the article
Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.
Abstract
IntroductionDysfunctional fan behavior represents a major concern in contemporary sports contexts. This study examines the association between collective narcissism, an exaggerated belief in the superiority of one’s group, and dysfunctional fan behavior. It investigates the moderating roles of stadium atmosphere and schadenfreude (pleasure derived from a rival’s misfortune) in this association.MethodsA cross-sectional, correlational design was employed. Data were collected through face-to-face surveys from 404 football fans residing in Istanbul, Ankara, and Izmir during the 2025–2026 football season. Collective narcissism, dysfunctional fan behavior, stadium atmosphere, and schadenfreude were assessed using established and adapted measurement instruments, and the psychometric properties of these instruments were evaluated in the…
Discussion
This study examined the main effect of collective narcissism on dysfunctional fan behavior and the moderating roles of stadium atmosphere and schadenfreude. The findings are interpreted in an integrated manner rather than discussed separately by hypothesis, to provide a more comprehensive theoretical understanding of the proposed relationships. Collective narcissism was positively associated with dysfunctional fan behavior (b = 0.087, p < 0.001), consistent with theoretical frameworks suggesting that collective narcissism heightens sensitivity to perceived threats to group identity and is associated with aggressive and exclusionary behavioral responses (Golec de Zavala et al., 2009; Cichocka, 2016; Golec de Zavala and Lantos, 2020). Individuals high in collective narcissism tend to compensate for the perceived underappreciation of…
Practical implications
The findings suggest that relevant stakeholders, including sport governing bodies and club management, may consider approaches that address the psychological and emotional dimensions of fan behavior, rather than relying exclusively on punitive measures. Structured fan engagement programs that promote respectful rivalry and constructive forms of identification represent one possible avenue, though the effectiveness of such initiatives would need to be evaluated through intervention-based research. At the same time, the buffering role of stadium atmosphere suggests that emotionally engaging match-day environments may help encourage collective enjoyment and socially regulated behavior through organized fan activities, coordinated chants, and inclusive match-day experiences. In contrast, the amplifying role of schadenfreude suggests that…
Editorial reading guide
- At what level—athlete, team, organization or system—was the evidence collected?
- Which actors control the decision, and which measures reveal unintended consequences?
