Creative Commons source reading · Sustainability and environmental impact
The Elite Sport Relevance Index: a five-dimensional framework for understanding value creation in elite sport
Van der Roest JW; Berkhout B
Originally published in Front Sports Act Living · 2026-10-19
From the article
Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.
Abstract
AbstractElite sport has traditionally derived its legitimacy from competitive success and international prestige. However, growing expectations concerning social responsibility, sustainability, economic accountability, and emotional engagement increasingly challenge this performance-centric rationale. Sport management research has addressed these developments across disparate strands, but lacks an integrative framework that captures elite sport relevance as a multidimensional and dynamic process of value creation. This article introduces the Elite Sport Relevance Index (ESRI), a conceptual framework comprising five interrelated dimensions: Performance, People, Planet, Profit, and Passion. Building on the Triple Bottom Line and sport-specific value frameworks, the ESRI conceptualizes elite sport as a value-creating system operating…
Discussion: governing interdependence and conflict across the five dimensions
Having introduced the five dimensions, the second part of this article shifts attention from individual value domains to their interaction. The value of the ESRI lies not in identifying five categories, but in making explicit the tensions, trade-offs, and choices between them. Elite sport organizations and systems continuously navigate multiple, interdependent dimensions that may reinforce one another or generate conflict over time. Understanding relevance therefore requires a dynamic view of how value is generated, how associated harms and costs are distributed, and how configurations are shaped by competing institutional logics (21–23). The interaction between the five dimensions can take the form of reinforcement or tension. The ESRI does not presume that the five dimensions can or should reach equilibrium. Some complementarities…
Conclusion and future research agenda
The ESRI reframes elite sport relevance as an ongoing governance challenge rather than a fixed outcome. Performance remains indispensable, but it becomes socially durable only when considered alongside the human, environmental, economic, and emotional values captured by People, Planet, Profit, and Passion. The framework's main contribution is therefore not the addition of four objectives to performance, but a vocabulary for making visible the complementarities, tensions, and trade-offs among value dimensions shaped by competing institutional logics. Leadership and governance mediate how those tensions are interpreted and embedded in strategy, resource allocation, partnerships, and accountability, but they cannot dissolve every structural conflict.
Editorial reading guide
- At what level—athlete, team, organization or system—was the evidence collected?
- Which actors control the decision, and which measures reveal unintended consequences?
