Journal DOI 10.68956/journal.human-performance-futures

Creative Commons source reading · Sport organizations and governance

Governing transgender athletes in global sport: fairness, evidence, media representation, and lived experience

Yi Chen Chiu; Ya Chun Shen

Originally published in Front Sports Act Living · 2026-05-26

From the article

Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.

Abstract

As gender diversity and gender identity have become increasingly central to contemporary public debate, the participation of transgender athletes in competitive sport has emerged as a highly contested issue at the intersection of science, law, governance, media, and human rights. Rather than treating this controversy as a simple opposition between fairness and inclusion, this article offers an integrative review of the major tensions shaping current debate. Drawing on academic studies, policy documents, media analyses, and first-person accounts published between 2015 and 2026, the article examines the issue through four interrelated dimensions: medical and physiological evidence, policy and legal developments, media and social narratives, and lived experience. The review shows that while testosterone, pubertal development, and related…

Conclusion

This article has examined the controversies surrounding transgender athletes' participation through four interrelated dimensions: medical and physiological evidence, policy and legal developments, media and social narratives, and lived experience. Overall, the review argues that the issue cannot be resolved by any single physiological indicator or reduced to a binary opposition between human rights and fairness. Rather, it is a complex governance problem shaped by scientific uncertainty, institutional design, political context, cultural representation, and embodied experience. At the medical and physiological level, existing evidence suggests that testosterone, male pubertal development, oxygen-carrying capacity, muscle mass, and strength are relevant to some aspects of performance, but findings remain inconsistent across sports,…

Editorial reading guide

  • At what level—athlete, team, organization or system—was the evidence collected?
  • Which actors control the decision, and which measures reveal unintended consequences?