Journal DOI 10.68956/journal.human-performance-futures

Creative Commons source reading · Team and collective performance

A systematic review and network meta-analysis on the effectiveness of exercise-based interventions for reducing the injury incidence in youth team-sport players. Part 1: an analysis by classical training components

Francisco Javier Robles-Palazón; Desirée Blázquez-Rincón; Alejandro López-Valenciano; Paul Comfort; José Antonio López-López; Francisco Ayala

Originally published in Ann Med · 2024-10-01

From the article

Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.

Abstract

AbstractObjectivesThe primary purposes were (a) to estimate the pooled effects of injury prevention programs (IPPs) on reducing overall and some specific body regions (lower extremity, thigh, knee, and ankle) injury incidence rates (IIRs) and (b) to compare the effects of single- and multi-component IPPs on mitigating injury risk in youth team sport athletes. A secondary objective was to explore the individual effects of different components on these IIRs.Materials and methodsSearches were performed up to 15 January 2024 in PubMed, Web of Science, SPORTDiscus, and Cochrane Library. Eligible criteria were: exercise-based interventions evaluated against a control group, overall IIRs were reported, and youth (≤19 years old) team sport players. Two reviewers extracted data and assessed trial quality using the Consolidated Standards of…

Discussion

The primary purposes of this systematic review and meta-analysis were (a) to estimate the pooled effects of IPPs on reducing overall and some specific body regions injury incidences, and (b) to compare the effects of S-IPPs and M-IPPs on mitigating injury risk in youth team sport athletes. A secondary objective was to explore the individual effects of different exercise-based components (i.e. strength, plyometrics, stability, speed & agility, coordination/warm-up drills, and flexibility) on the injury incidences previously mentioned. To address these objectives, data extracted from 21 eligible studies were analyzed according to three different levels of concretion. Next, the main findings obtained from these three levels of analysis are presented and discussed separately.

Conclusions

Evidence coming from 21 different studies suggests that exercise-based injury prevention programs may reduce overall, lower extremity, thigh, knee, and ankle injuries in youth team sport athletes by 35%. Most of the S-IPPs and M-IPPs implemented in the included studies demonstrated statistically significant risk mitigation effects for overall and lower extremity injuries and thus, we advise against recommending standard practices or sham exercises (i.e. the usual control group in RCTs) as an injury prevention strategy. Our results also indicate that interventions comprising strength and flexibility exercises, and likely those incorporating stability exercises, might be the most effective measures for reducing injury incidence in youth team sports. However, this statement should be considered with caution and serve as a starting point…

Editorial reading guide

  • At what level—athlete, team, organization or system—was the evidence collected?
  • Which actors control the decision, and which measures reveal unintended consequences?