Journal DOI 10.68956/journal.human-performance-futures

Creative Commons source reading · Sport organizations and governance

Charting the Scientific Landscape of Indirect Estimation Models in Doping Prevalence Research: A Bibliometric Analysis with Narrative Appraisal

Petróczi A; Sagoe D; Kiss A; Soós S; Chegeni R; Veltmaat A; Cruyff M; van der Heijden P; de Hon O

Originally published in Sports (Basel) · 2026-06-03

From the article

Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.

Abstract

AbstractInterpreting doping prevalence estimates generated through indirect estimation models (IEMs) remains challenging for sport policy and governance due to the wide variation in reported rates and methodological complexity. In this study, we combined a critical appraisal of the methodological and epistemic developments of IEM applications to doping prevalence with a bibliometric analysis of publication trends, citation patterns, and collaboration networks, using a convergent parallel mixed-methods design. Across 52 records published between 2002 and 2026, this study maps the scientific landscape of IEM-based doping prevalence research. Findings show that IEM-based prevalence research is methodologically sophisticated yet institutionally dispersed and largely Eurocentric, reflecting a field still consolidating its standards and…

3. Results

The number of published studies increases only gradually over the observed period, indicating a relatively slow expansion of the evidence base, with the number of outputs fluctuating between two and five per year (see Figure 2). In contrast, the number of unique researchers involved shows a more pronounced upward trend. This divergence suggests that, while growth in outputs remains modest, IEM-based doping prevalence estimation is attracting an increasingly broader research community, pointing to a slowly rising methodological interest and collaborative engagement beyond what is reflected by publication counts alone.

4. Integrated Results and Narrative Insights

Against the rich literature on IEMs, spanning over half a century [20,21,120], their application to doping only began around the turn of the millennium [84,90], with the first full publication in English appearing in 2006 [100]. Our findings indicate limited variability in study origin, with the majority of studies included in the meta-analysis conducted in European countries. Bibliometric analyses revealed that this trend was primarily driven by the dominance of two closely linked but distinct research groups in Germany. Over time, however, the trends show the emergence of new research groups in the United Kingdom and the Netherlands. WADA’s establishment of a Working Group on Prevalence of Doping in Sport (2017–2023), with its focus on survey development [121], also facilitated the observed expansion in outputs, authorship, and…

Editorial reading guide

  • At what level—athlete, team, organization or system—was the evidence collected?
  • Which actors control the decision, and which measures reveal unintended consequences?