Journal DOI 10.68956/journal.human-performance-futures

Creative Commons source reading · Tracking and video

Penalty kick or not? Differences in the interpretation of handball incidents in professional association football

Bauch T; Leyhr D; Schmidt D; Brinkmann D; Höner O

Originally published in Source journal · 2026-02-25

From the article

Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.

Abstract

AbstractHandball decisions in the penalty area remain one of the most controversial topics in professional association football, yet they are underexplored in sports science. The purpose of this research was to establish a foundation for understanding the controversy by examining its underlying causes. Two video-based studies quantified how key stakeholders interpret handball incidents and how closely these interpretations align with Union of European Football Associations (UEFA) guidelines. Study 1 involved referees active in German men’s professional football (n = 154) who judged 30 incidents. Study 2 repeated the procedure with professional coaches (n = 31) and players (n = 46) using 18 incidents. Outcomes were Accuracy (accordance with UEFA), Strictness (percentage of incidents deemed punishable), Consensus (within- and…

Editorial reading guide

  • How were tactical actions measured or coded?
  • How well does the evidence account for opponent, game state and level of play?