Journal DOI 10.68956/journal.human-performance-futures

Creative Commons source reading · Strength and conditioning

The alliance formation puzzle in contests with capacity-constraints: A test using American football reception-coverage contest data

Justin Ehrlich; Matthew Harmon; Shane Sanders

Originally published in Source journal · 2020-03-04

From the article

Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.

Abstract

We utilize a contest-theoretic model to demonstrate a version of the alliance formation puzzle that aligns with reception-coverage contests in American football. Namely, secondary defenders can opt for single-coverage—1 v 1 contest. Alternatively, they can choose to ally—form double-coverage or 2 v 1 contest with exogenous intra-alliance prize division—when defending a given receiver. In our theoretical treatment, we find that defenses have a lower equilibrium success rate in preventing the receiver from “getting open” under double-coverage than under single-coverage in the absence of capacity constraints. We also find that this success rate paradox is a necessary condition for the alliance formation puzzle. We then test the theoretical treatment by analyzing 8,508 plays of NCAA and NFL game data within a set of fixed effects,…

Editorial reading guide

  • Which positions and levels of play were measured?
  • How did the researchers measure movement, workload or adaptation?