Journal DOI 10.68956/journal.international-computational-law

International Computational Law Journal · Volume 2

From Legal Code to Legal Intelligence

Browse the journal archive, with original article records, source attribution and reading agents.

In this volume

Source reading · Generative AI & Legal Reasoning

Identifying a Set of Autonomous Levels for AI-Based Computational Legal Reasoning

Computational law is currently bereft of a defined set of autonomous levels for differentiating AI-based capacities in legal reasoning. This paper provides a strawman proposal for establishing a standard for such autonomous levels and seeks to activate a vital and vigorous discussion to aid in progress toward putting in place a suitable and industry-wide Levels of Autonomy (LoA) framework for AI-based Legal Reasoning (AILR) systems.

Source reading · Generative AI & Legal Reasoning

Law and Computation: A Conversation

This conversation between a computer scientist and a lawyer/technologist – about evolving collaborations across their several disciplines – was triggered by interactions at the SubTech’conference in Singapore in July 2022. Together with Alexis Chun they recently published Using Domain-Specific Languages in Legal Applications in The Journal of Robotics, Artificial Intelligence & Law.

Source reading · Generative AI & Legal Reasoning

A Path Toward Legal Autonomy: An Interoperable and Explainable Approach to Extracting, Transforming, Loading, and Computing Legal Information Using Large Language Models, Expert Systems, and Bayesian Networks

Legal autonomy -- the lawful activity of artificial intelligence agents -- can be achieved in one of two ways. It can be achieved either by imposing constraints on AI actors such as developers, deployers and users, and on AI resources such as data, or by imposing constraints on the range and scope of the impact that AI agents can have on the environment. The latter approach involves encoding extant rules concerning AI driven devices into the software of AI agents controlling those devices (e.g., encoding rules about limitations on zones of operations into the agent software of an autonomous drone device). This is a challenge since the effectivity of such an approach requires a method of extracting, loading, transforming and computing legal information that would be both explainable and legally interoperable, and that would enable AI agents to “reason” about the law. In this paper, we sketch a proof of principle for such a method using large language models (LLMs), expert legal systems known as legal decision paths, and Bayesian networks. We then show how the proposed method could be applied to extant regulation in matters of autonomous cars, such as the California Vehicle Code.

Source reading · Generative AI & Legal Reasoning

The Dawn of a New Era of Compliance: Automated Compliance Verification and Enforcement

The escalating complexity of regulatory environments poses significant challenges to traditional compliance systems, which are inadequate for handling dynamic, unbounded tasks involving large volumes of unstructured and ambiguous data. We introduce an AI-based compliance verification framework leveraging Generative AI and Large Language Models (LLMs) to systematically address these issues. The framework comprises three components: (1) Knowledge Acquisition—extracting and structuring rules from unstructured texts into an ontology; (2) the Verification Language Model (VER-LLM)—applying logical reasoning and hypothesis testing to navigate rule ambiguities and assess compliance; and (3) Continuous Improvement—a feedback mechanism that refines the system's reasoning by identifying and resolving ambiguities in compliance requirements. The VER-LLM is trained on synthetically generated data derived from real compliance cases, ensuring privacy while capturing the nuanced patterns necessary for effective verification. Experimental results indicate that our framework outperforms the traditional LLM approach in accuracy, adaptability, and scalability, providing a real-time solution that adjusts to evolving regulations. This work significantly advances compliance verification, offering enterprises a sophisticated tool for accurate and efficient compliance enforcement.