Journal DOI 10.68956/journal.legal-engineering-technology

Creative Commons source reading · Legal knowledge representation

Argumentation and Defeasible Reasoning in the Law

Marco Billi; Roberta Calegari; Giuseppe Contissa; Francesca Lagioia; Giuseppe Pisano; Galileo Sartor; Giovanni Sartor

Originally published in J · 2021-12-18

From the article

Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.

Abstract

Different formalisms for defeasible reasoning have been used to represent knowledge and reason in the legal field. In this work, we provide an overview of the following logic-based approaches to defeasible reasoning: defeasible logic, Answer Set Programming, ABA+, ASPIC+, and DeLP. We compare features of these approaches under three perspectives: the logical model (knowledge representation), the method (computational mechanisms), and the technology (available software resources). On top of that, two real examples in the legal domain are designed and implemented in ASPIC+ to showcase the benefit of an argumentation approach in real-world domains. The CrossJustice and Interlex projects are taken as a testbed, and experiments are conducted with the Arg2P technology.

Editorial reading guide

  • Which legal requirement is represented, and which assumptions does that representation introduce?
  • How could a practitioner test the result against an ambiguous or exceptional case?