Journal DOI 10.68956/journal.legal-engineering-technology

Creative Commons source reading · Legal knowledge representation

Defending parenthood: A look at parents' legal argumentation in Norwegian care order appeal proceedings

Ida Benedicte Juhasz

Originally published in Child & Family Social Work · 2018-03-30

From the article

Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.

Abstract

This paper examines parents' legal argumentation in 15 appealed care order (child removal) cases in one Norwegian district court, asking on what grounds parents appeal their case. I investigate the pragmatic, ethical, and moral bases in arguments by applying a discourse ethics framework, viewing argumentation as either justifications or excuses of the parenting in question. The analysis reveals complex reasons for appealing, displaying parents both justifying and excusing both specific situations and the totality of their parenthood. Parents primarily apply pragmatic and ethical adversarialism, followed by pragmatic blaming and claims of change, moral justifications about due process, and ethical excuses about age and own life histories. Interestingly, normalization emerges as a third strategy, where parents explicitly aim to widen the scope of parental normality and adequacy, challenging the common defense dichotomy. The study provides new insight into an important and sensitive field, and indicates that parents engage in similar concrete strategies when, most often unsuccessfully, defending their parenthood.

Editorial reading guide

  • Which legal requirement is represented, and which assumptions does that representation introduce?
  • How could a practitioner test the result against an ambiguous or exceptional case?