Creative Commons source reading · Digital courts and procedure
Judging with Practical Wisdom in Digital Courts: Paul Ricœur’s Little Ethics and the Ethical Governance of AI in the Judiciary
Erwin Susilo
Originally published in Ceniiac · 2026-02-16
From the article
Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.
Abstract
Since 2025, a significant number of judicial systems in various countries have adopted or are testing the use of digital technology and artificial intelligence (AI), particularly in pre-trial risk assessment, sentencing support, and case management. Despite promising efficiency, this practice raises serious issues regarding algorithmic bias, lack of transparency, and judicial legitimacy, as reflected in the use of COMPAS in the United States and the cancelation of the SyRI system in the Netherlands. This research seeks to redefine judicial ethics as a normative framework for the regulation of AI-assisted decision-making. This study employs the normative legal research method within a hermeneutic framework, incorporating a philosophical analysis of Paul Ricoeur's concept of petite éthique, a conceptual approach, and a comparative examination of constitutional and supreme court decisions in Germany, South Africa, and Indonesia. The primary outcome of this research is the development of the Reflective Judicial Phronesis Model, which conceptualizes phronesis as both a personal virtue of judges and an institutional reflective capability within digital judicial governance. This research concludes that institutional adaptation of Ricœur's ethics provides a normative basis for strengthening reasoning transparency, human control over AI, and the legitimacy and accountability of technolo
Editorial reading guide
- Whose experience is measured, and who might be missing from the evidence?
- How does the proposed design affect the ability to participate, understand a decision or seek review?
