Journal DOI 10.68956/journal.legal-engineering-technology

Creative Commons source reading · Evaluation, bias and explainability

Modeling Motivated Reasoning in Law: Evaluating Strategic Role Conditioning in LLM Summarization

Eunjung Cho; Alexander Miserlis Hoyle; Yoan Hermstrüwer

Originally published in Proceedings of the Natural Legal Language Processing Workshop 2025 · 2025-11

From the article

Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.

Abstract

Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly used to generate user-tailored summaries, adapting outputs to specific stakeholders. In legal contexts, this raises important questions about motivated reasoning — how models strategically frame information to align with a stakeholder’s position within the legal system. Building on theories of legal realism and recent trends in legal practice, we investigate how LLMs respond to prompts conditioned on different legal roles (e.g., judges, prosecutors, attorneys) when summarizing judicial decisions. We introduce an evaluation framework grounded in legal fact and reasoning inclusion, also considering favorability towards stakeholders. Our results show that even when prompts include balancing instructions, models exhibit selective inclusion patterns that reflect role-consistent perspectives. These findings raise broader concerns about how similar alignment may emerge as LLMs begin to infer user roles from prior interactions or context, even without explicit role instructions.

Editorial reading guide

  • Which legal corpus, jurisdiction and evaluation task does the article use?
  • What evidence supports the reported performance, and where could the method fail in practice?