Creative Commons source reading · Digital evidence and admissibility
The admissibility of digital evidence from open-source forensic tools: Development of a framework for legal acceptance
Isa Ismail; Khairul Akram Zainol Ariffin
Originally published in PLOS One · 2025-09-12
From the article
Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.
Abstract
The proliferation of cybercriminal activities from 2023 to 2025 has highlighted the critical role of digital forensics in legal proceedings; however, resource constraints often limit access to effective investigative capabilities. Despite the technical adequacy of open-source digital forensic tools, courts typically favor commercially validated solutions because of the absence of standardized validation frameworks for open-source alternatives, creating unnecessary financial barriers to high-quality forensic investigations. This study aims to validate and enhance the conceptual open-source digital forensic framework developed by Ismail et al. (2024) to ensure the legal admissibility of evidence acquired through open-source tools. Through a rigorous experimental methodology utilizing controlled testing environments, we conducted comparative analyses between commercial tools (FTK and Forensic MagiCube) and open-source alternatives (Autopsy and ProDiscover Basic) across three distinct test scenarios: preservation and collection of original data, recovery of deleted files through data carving, and targeted artifact searching. Each experiment was performed in triplicate to establish repeatability metrics, with error rates calculated by comparing the acquired artifacts with control references. Our findings demonstrate that properly validated open-source tools consistently produce reli
Editorial reading guide
- Which legal framework, data lifecycle or evidentiary standard applies in the article?
- How do the authors establish integrity or accountability, and what remains unverified?
