Opinion text
This transcription is from Harvard’s Caselaw Access Project. The signed section appears below. The source includes the full case and any shared notes.
POSNER, Circuit Judge, with whom BAUER, HARLINGTON WOOD, Jr., and COFFEY, Circuit Judges, join, concurring.
I join in all but Parts III and V of Judge Eschbach’s thorough and meticulous opinion. Part III holds that an FBI agent may bring a .damages suit for an alleged violation of his constitutional rights brought about by a transfer from one FBI office to another. Part Y holds that one does not give up his right of free speech by becoming an FBI agent. In view of the disposition of the case, neither Part III nor Part V is essential to the court’s decision, and Part III in particular reaches a conclusion that I find difficult to accept. I would think it the better part of valor to avoid trying to resolve either question in this case.
In a recent decision not cited by the court, Jones v. Reagan, 696 F.2d 551 (7th Cir.1983), a panel of this court held that members of an army reserve unit could not bring a damages action for alleged violation of their constitutional rights brought about by a transfer from one reserve unit to another. The case is distinguishable from this case on several grounds but I am not convinced that this case should be decided differently, in view of the potential disruptive effect of damages liability on the FBI’s ability to maintain discipline and cohesion. I also am not completely persuaded that FBI agents have a First Amendment right to criticize their superiors. The adverse effect of such a right on discipline and cohesion may outweigh the benefits of allowing FBI agents to participate fully in the marketplace of ideas.
If I thought either of these issues was inescapably presented by this case I would roll up my sleeves and grapple with them and maybe in the end would be persuaded by Judge Eschbach’s analysis. But since they are at once difficult and inessential I would prefer to see the court defer their resolution until a case arises where they are inescapably presented. As only four of the eight judges voting have joined in Parts III and V, in effect the court has deferred their resolution to another day.
. It is not clear to me, under this analysis (assuming that it is correct), how progress in the development of the law is to be accomplished since defendants presumably will be able to avoid liability in unprecedented situations by invoking the Harlow defense. Whether a court could recognize a defendant’s right to immunity but then go on to hold the conduct complained of illegal for future cases would seem to raise serious Article III problems as well as removing the incentive of plaintiffs to advance contentions requiring a change in the law. See Stovall v. Denno, 388 U.S. 293, 301, 87 S.Ct. 1967, 1972, 18 L.Ed.2d 1199 (1967). See generally Mackey v. United States, 401 U.S. 667, 675-702, 91 S.Ct. 1160, 1164-1165, 28 L.Ed.2d 404 (Harlan, J., dissenting).
. Whatever else may be said about Egger’s concerns, they assumed sufficient public importance and reality to become the subject of a national network television story on the ABC news program, “20/20” (November 4, 1982).
