Journal DOI 10.68956/dyh5-kwte

Creative Commons source reading · Neurosurgical oncology

An update on tests used for intraoperative monitoring of cognition during awake craniotomy.

Beleke de Zwart; Carla Ruis

Originally published in Acta neurochirurgica · 2024-05-07

From the article

Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.

Abstract

Purpose Mapping higher-order cognitive functions during awake brain surgery is important for cognitive preservation which is related to postoperative quality of life. A systematic review from 2018 about neuropsychological tests used during awake craniotomy made clear that until 2017 language was most often monitored and that the other cognitive domains were underexposed (Ruis, J Clin Exp Neuropsychol 40(10):1081-1104, 218). The field of awake craniotomy and cognitive monitoring is however developing rapidly. The aim of the current review is therefore, to investigate whether there is a change in the field towards incorporation of new tests and more complete mapping of (higher-order) cognitive functions. Methods We replicated the systematic search of the study from 2018 in PubMed and Embase from February 2017 to November 2023, yielding 5130 potentially relevant articles. We used the artificial machine learning tool ASReview for screening and included 272 papers that gave a detailed description of the neuropsychological tests used during awake craniotomy.

Results

An overview of the final 272 included studies in this quantitative synthesis is presented in Table 1, with each cognitive domain and used test outlined per article. Standardized neuropsychological tests are presented in italic. Figure 2 presents a comparison of the percentual cognitive domains that were monitored, in order to compare our results with the reported domains in the work of 2018 [221]. As visible, the vast majority (90.4%) of included studies tested the language domain (Fig. 2). In 40% of these studies, only the language domain was tested, compared to 68% in previous work.

Discussion

With the shifted focus towards more extensive monitoring of cognition and more person-centered care, we created an overview to see whether the scope of tests used during awake craniotomy has broadened and we present the most important changes over the last years. First and foremost, the language domain continues to be by far the most extensively, and most often, monitored domain during the surgical procedures. It is not surprising that language is such an integral part of almost all awake craniotomies, since this function is highly related to quality of life [82].

Conclusion

In conclusion, the current study indicates that there is a positive trend towards implementation of a broader range of tests during awake brain surgery. We see a shift towards more extensive monitoring during the procedures, especially in the domains of motor functioning, social cognition, visuospatial processing, and executive functioning. In order to achieve more extensive cognitive monitoring, implementations of new tests, revised tests, or digital versions of more traditional neuropsychological tests during surgery offer opportunities for the future.

Editorial reading guide

  • How were patients or cases selected, and what did the authors use as a comparator?
  • Which outcomes, complications and follow-up intervals determine how far the findings apply?