Creative Commons source reading · Language and cognitive rehabilitation
Conversation focused aphasia therapy: investigating the adoption of strategies by people with agrammatism.
Suzanne Beeke; Firle Beckley; Fiona Johnson; Claudia Heilemann; Susan Edwards; Jane Maxim; Wendy Best
Originally published in Aphasiology · 2015-03-01
From the article
Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.
Abstract
Background : A recent review of interaction (or conversation)-focused therapy highlighted the potential of programmes targeting the person with aphasia (PWA) directly. However, it noted the key limitations of current work in this field to be a reliance on single case analyses and qualitative evidence of change, a situation that is not unusual when a complex behavioural intervention is in the early stages of development and evaluation. Aims : This article aims to evaluate an intervention that targeted a PWA and their conversation partner (CP), a dyad, as equals in a novel conversation therapy for agrammatic aphasia, using both quantitative and qualitative evidence of change. The intervention aimed to increase the insight of a dyad into facilitator and barrier conversation behaviours, to increase the understanding of the effect of agrammatism on communication, and to support each speaker to choose three strategies to work on in therapy to increase mutual understanding and enhance conversation. Methods & Procedures : Quantitative and qualitative methods are used to analyse multiple pre-therapy and follow up assessments of conversation for two dyads.
Methods and procedures
Each case study involved a PWA and their chosen CP in 6 months of intervention, subdivided into three phases of 8 weeks each: (a) pre-therapy baseline assessment; (b) therapy; and (c) post-therapy follow up assessment. Figure 1 illustrates the design. Figure 1. Study design.
Results
We predicted that there would be an increase in behaviours targeted as helpful in conversation (facilitators) and a decrease in behaviours deemed unhelpful (barriers). Here we present results of statistical analysis of strategies chosen by the PWA and by the CP (deemed facilitatory behaviours), and CP barriers, for six pre- and six post-therapy conversation samples, to identify whether therapy had a significant effect on conversation. This section is followed by a qualitative analysis of conversation extracts that explores how the turns taken by the PWA and CP changed after therapy.
Discussion and clinical implications
This article reports the quantitative and qualitative therapy outcomes of conversation training for two dyads where one speaker has agrammatic aphasia. The quantitative results reveal that therapy had a significant effect on both speakers of one dyad, Alex (CP) and Graham (PWA), but only on the CP of the other dyad, Pamela, and not on Stuart (PWA). Thus, Alex almost eradicated test questions from his talk after therapy, having identified this as a barrier behaviour that he wished to change.
Editorial reading guide
- How did the authors define recovery, and when did they measure it?
- Does the outcome reflect a laboratory measure, a functional change or participation in daily life?
