Journal DOI 10.68956/dyh5-kwte

Creative Commons source reading · Traumatic brain injury recovery

Mild traumatic brain injury recovery: a growth curve modelling analysis over 2 years.

Ellen L Carroll; Joanne G Outtrim; Faye Forsyth; Anne E Manktelow; Peter J A Hutchinson; Olli Tenovuo; Jussi P Posti; Lindsay Wilson; Barbara J Sahakian; David K Menon; Virginia F J Newcombe

Originally published in Journal of neurology · 2020-06-13

From the article

Selected source text. JournalOS removes markup and shortens excerpts where indicated. The full article provides the complete context.

Abstract

Background An improved understanding of the trajectory of recovery after mild traumatic brain injury is important to be able to understand individual patient outcomes, for longitudinal patient care and to aid the design of clinical trials. Objective To explore changes in health, well-being and cognition over the 2 years following mTBI using latent growth curve (LGC) modelling. Methods Sixty-one adults with mTBI presenting to a UK Major Trauma Centre completed comprehensive longitudinal assessment at up to five time points after injury: 2 weeks, 3 months, 6 months, 1 year and 2 years. Results Persisting problems were seen with neurological symptoms, cognitive issues and poor quality of life measures including 28% reporting incomplete recovery on the Glasgow Outcome Score Extended at 2 years. Harmful drinking, depression, psychological distress, disability, episodic memory and working memory did not improve significantly over the 2 years following injury. For other measures, including the Rivermead Post-Concussion Symptoms and Quality of Life after Brain Injury (QOLIBRI), LGC analysis revealed significant improvement over time with recovery tending to plateau at 3-6 months.

Results

Table 1 presents participant demographic and injury characteristics. The majority of participants with mTBI (77%) were GCS 15 on arrival, although patients with GCS 13 (5%) and GCS 14 (18%) were also represented. Sixty-nine percent were male, and the age range 17–84 years [mean = 42.0 years, Standard Deviation (SD) ± 17.77]. The estimated premorbid IQ range was 97–124 (mean = 113.72, SD ± 7.22) using the National Adult Reading Test (NART) [36].

Discussion

This study examined recovery from mTBI over 2 years and found that ongoing symptoms were common for the entire period. Importantly, it is the first study to report functional, quality of life and neurocognitive outcomes over such a long time period. Although improvement was rapid early on (before plateauing) for post-concussion symptoms (significant improvement up to 3 months) and GOSE, scores fell below trauma control norms at every time point.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that, for some individuals, recovery from mTBI occurs over a long timescale and is much more protracted than usually believed. In particular, problems with emotional well-being, alcohol use and cognition, as well as symptoms such as headaches and sleep disturbance, are common after mTBI and often long-standing. Further LGC modelling in larger samples and over longer time frames will enable exploration of casual factors whilst providing the power to detect potential individual differences in the rate of change over time.

Editorial reading guide

  • How did the authors define recovery, and when did they measure it?
  • Does the outcome reflect a laboratory measure, a functional change or participation in daily life?