Journal DOI 10.68956/journal.family-office-private-wealth

Journal Opal · Research guides

Read the source.
Ask its paper.

Search attributed records and open each reading agent. Original publication details, rights and evidence coverage remain on the individual paper.

Research article · Capital with Conviction · Private capital & investment governance

Sector-based portfolio changes of private equity funds during economic shocks

Private equity investments are highly sensitive to economic shocks due to their assets' high leverage and illiquidity. Allocations to PE have significantly increased over the past decade; research on portfolio selections during economic shocks however remains scarce. We bridge this gap by analyzing sector-level re-allocations during three global economic shocks (the DotCom-bust, the Global Financial Crisis, and COVID-19). We do so by comparing the share of sectoral capital six months before each shock with capital allocations made during the shocks, using a dataset of more than 53,000 buy-side transactions. Specific sectors showed increased transactions from PE investors across all shocks, indicating positive perception from investors in times of uncertainty. Our findings entail: Limited Partners need to critically assess industry-orientated investments of General Partners and challenge over-allocation in perceived “safe harbor” industries, especially when General Partners have no specialization in these industries. When the General Partners are industry-specialized, however, Limited Partners can unlock significant return potential when they agree to an extended investment period. For General Partners with expertise in sagging industries, shocks offer investment opportunities as competition shies away and valuations decrease. Companies in sagging industries seeking external capital should target sources other than PE or accept increased return expectations.

Research article · Capital with Conviction · Private capital & investment governance

A world of difference? The impact of corporate venture capitalists’ investment motivation on startup valuation

Corporate venture capital (CVC) investors are regularly painted with the same brush, a fact underscored by the often observed belief in the extant literature that corporate venture capitalists (CVCs) form a homogeneous group. In contrast to this simplifying perspective, this paper categorizes CVCs into subgroups by examining their levels of strategic and financial investment motivation using computer-aided text analysis and cluster analysis. To validate the resulting clusters, this paper studies the impact of CVC type on startup valuation from an intra - group perspective by applying hierarchical linear modeling, thus illustrating which particular investment motivation might be preferable to others in the context of negotiating valuations. An empirical analysis of 52 CVC mission statements and 147 startup valuations between January 2009 and January 2016 revealed that first, CVCs with a strategic investment motivation assign lower startup valuations than CVCs with an analytic motivation that have moderate levels of the two scrutinized dimensions, suggesting that entrepreneurs trade off these CVCs’ value-adding contributions against a valuation discount; second, CVCs with an unfocused investment motivation pay significantly higher purchase prices, thus supporting the hypothesis that they have a so-called liability of vacillation; and third, the valuations of CVCs with a financial investment motive are not significantly different from those of their analytic peers. In sum, our results add to the knowledge of the continuum of corporate investors’ investment motivation by illustrating how startup valuations differ across CVC types.

Research article · Capital with Conviction · Private capital & investment governance

Cross-border buyout pricing

Using a dataset of 1149 global private equity transactions, we find that cross-border buyouts are associated with significantly higher valuation multiples than domestic ones. We attribute this finding to informational disadvantages of foreign acquirers. Consistent with this idea, we find that the spread in valuation multiples narrows when the target operates in a country with high accounting standards, when it was publicly listed prior to the buyout, and when information production is facilitated due to large firm size. Further results suggest that local partnering in a syndicate serves as an effective remedy to avoid adverse pricing effects. The spread in valuation multiples is also less pronounced for large buyout funds, presumably because they draw on sufficient organizational resources to cope with cross-border-related transaction costs.

Research article · Capital with Conviction · Private capital & investment governance

Determining Drivers of Private Equity Return with Computational Approaches

Private equity (PE) represents the acquisition of stakes in non-listed companies, often long-term, with the objective of improving the performance and value of the company to obtain significant benefits at time of disinvestment. PE has gained particular importance in the global financial system for delivering superior risk-adjusted returns. Knowing the PE return drivers has been of great interest among researchers and academics, and some studies have developed statistical models to determine PE return drivers. Still, the explanatory capacity of these models has certain limitations related to their precision levels and exclusive focus on groups of countries located in Europe and the EE.UU. Therefore, in the current literature, new models of analysis of the PE return drivers are demanded to provide a better fit in worldwide scenarios. This study contributes to the accuracy of the models that identify the PE return drivers using computational methods and a sample of 1606 PE funds with a geographical focus on the world ’ s five regions. The results have provided a unique set of PE return drivers with a precision level above 86%. The conclusions obtained present important theoretical and practical implications, expanding knowledge about PE and financial forecasting from a global perspective.

Research article · Capital with Conviction · Private capital & investment governance

Profitability of private equity: mean reversion and transitory shocks

This paper deals with the analysis of the statistical properties of the profitability yielded by Private Equity from a fractionally integrated viewpoint. Using quarterly data from 1981q2 to 2021q3, the results support the hypothesis of stationarity and mean reversion in all cases; however, we observe differences in the degree of persistence across regions, Europe being the closest to short memory while the US shows the highest degree of long range dependence and thus the longer lasting effects of shocks. Some policy recommendations of the results obtained are included at the end of the manuscript.

Research article · Capital with Conviction · Private capital & investment governance

Investing in Your Alumni: Endowments’ Investment Choices in Private Equity

We investigate the role of alumni ties in university endowments’ decision to invest into private equity funds. Based on a sample of 1,590 commitments made by 189 U.S. endowments into 613 funds during the period of 1995 to 2017, we show that endowments are more likely to invest into funds that are managed by the alumni of their own alma mater. This finding is more pronounced for less prestigious and less private equity experienced university endowments. Thus, our results are not only dominated by institutions with a larger proportion of active alumni in the private equity industry. Furthermore, we observe that alumni ties are not associated with better performance compared to other endowment investments where such a tie does not exist.

Research article · Capital with Conviction · Private capital & investment governance

VC investors’ venture screening: the role of the decision maker’s education and experience

We assess whether and how VC investors’ education and experience influence their screening decisions of potential investee candidates. Empirically, we perform an experimental choice-based-conjoint (CBC) analysis with 564 individual VC investors. Our results highlight that the level and field of education, as well as the decision maker’s investment and entrepreneurial experience, moderate the relative importance of different screening criteria. More specifically, we find that international scalability seems to become more important for decision makers with higher education and those with entrepreneurial experience. Whereas decision makers with a background in natural science focus on the value-added of the product or service, engineers seem to value a break even profitability and focus less on the management team. Investment experience, on the other hand, leads to a stronger focus on the management team. Our study contributes to the literature investigating the influence of human capital characteristics of the decision maker in venture financing. Practical implications exist for entrepreneurial ventures seeking financing and for risk capital investors making investments in such ventures.

Research article · Capital with Conviction · Private capital & investment governance

Navigating the Ambiguity of Impact Investing: How Impact Venture Capitalists Access New Markets, Founders, and Capital

Despite the growing prominence of impact investing in both research and practice, the definition of social and environmental impact remains contested. Rather than resolving the elusiveness of impact, we examine how impact venture capitalists (IVCs) leverage this ambiguity in their everyday practices. Drawing on Michel de Certeau’s philosophy of everyday life, we identify three tactical ways in which IVCs navigate this ambiguity. First, IVCs use ambiguity to move sideways into new markets, distinguishing themselves from traditional investors. Second, they tactically employ ambiguity to attract limited partner (LP) capital earmarked for impact investments. Finally, they leverage ambiguity to forge connections with founders of high-growth ventures, thereby gaining a competitive edge in deal-making. We discuss the ethical dimension of these tactics, highlighting how the normative question of what constitutes social and environmental change arises from the practical use of the ambiguous term impact. In doing so, we identify an ethical tension: while the flexibility of the term impact fosters new ways of thinking about social and environmental change, it also risks being used for purely financial gain. We conclude by reflecting on the implications of this ethical tension for both the practice and research of impact investing.

Research article · Capital with Conviction · Private capital & investment governance

Ethical Sensemaking in Impact Investing: Reasons and Motives in the Chinese Renewable Energy Sector

This article explores impact investing within the renewable energy sector. Drawing on ethical decision making and sensemaking, this article contributes to an enhanced understanding of the complex ethical sensemaking process of impact investors when facing plausible situations in a world of contested truths. Addressing the ethical tensions faced by impact investors with mixed motives, this study investigates the way decision makers use context-specific reasons to make sense of and shape the renewable energy investment (REI) process. This represents an initial attempt to understand ethical sensemaking in impact investing made within the renewable energy (RE) sector using a multi-stakeholder approach. Our findings show that prosocial, personal, reputational, and economic motives are the main drivers of REI, with prosocial and personal motives being value-based, and reputational and economic motives being evidence-based. We find three different modes of ethical sensemaking (pragmatic, retrospective, and forecasting), allowing for the construction of the four motives noted above. These motives are based on the context-specific reasons of impact investing decision makers in the RE sector. This article contributes to the academic discourse on ethical sensemaking with some key processes involved in ethical decision making, and a better understanding of the underlying motivations of impact investing in the RE sector.

Research article · Capital with Conviction · Private capital & investment governance

Green signals of new ventures: investigating the impact of environmental orientation on funding and the moderating role of lead venture capitalists

Drawing on signaling theory, this study investigates whether the environmental orientation of new ventures serves as an important signal related to funding outcomes. Analyzing a dataset of 2003 funding rounds completed in the U.S. during 2022, our findings reveal that the environmental orientation of a new venture positively influences pre-IPO funding outcomes. Furthermore, this effect is positively moderated by the prominence of lead venture capital investors. Our post hoc analysis offers a valuable temporal perspective and suggests that our findings generalize across both early-stage and late-stage funding rounds, but not seed funding. This study contributes to the literature on financial resource acquisition and signaling theory, and also offers valuable implications for practitioners, helping them navigate the competitive funding environment more effectively.

Research article · Capital with Conviction · Private capital & investment governance

Value, Values, and Valuation: The Marketization of Charitable Foundation Impact Investing

Based on an abductive analytic study, we examine financial and social value incorporation in the multi-valued market of impact investing. This paper draws on interviews with investment professionals in 54 charitable foundations, intermediary and field building organizations in the impact investing market, to compare market objectives with practice, and to determine whether social and financial values are incorporated, thus producing ‘returns’ of both types through market exchange. We find unincorporated valuation is apparent at both the market level and for several types of investors in contrast with the incorporated or even integrated valuations of other investors. This demonstrates that rather than incorporating logics in a binary or hybrid way, valuation in the moral market of impact investing occurs in a multiplicity of ways and on different levels of the market, depending on a variety of factors including adherence to traditional financial market standards and market design and maintenance.

Research article · Capital with Conviction · Private capital & investment governance

From ambition to evidence: a practical tool for startup impact assessment

Impact-driven startups face major challenges in measuring and reporting their social and environmental impacts. In a related manner, impact investors face challenges when attempting to assess the impact of startups. This is primarily due to a lack of comparability and transparency. Despite the proliferation of tools and frameworks, a misfit persists between the capabilities of startups and the expectations of investors. Resource constraints have a significant impact on the capacity of startups to engage in complex impact measurement. Current impact assessment tools are often ill-suited to the needs of startups, as they require extensive data that smaller companies may not have readily available. The present study proposes a design science research approach to derive design knowledge for the impact assessment of startups and subsequently develop a new tool tailored to the needs of startups. The purpose of this tool is to enable startups to measure and report their potential impact efficiently. The objective is to enhance transparency, comparability, and legitimacy, thereby helping startups attract investment while aligning their business activities with their social and environmental missions.

Research article · The Resilient Estate · Real estate & resilience

Liquidity and prices: a cluster analysis of the German residential real estate market

This paper analyses the highly under-researched German residential real estate market. Quality- and spatial-adjusted price and liquidity indices are calculated separately for the investment and rental market on a regional basis. Applying the “Partitioning Around Medoids (PAM)” clustering algorithm, the regions are clustered with respect to their price and liquidity development after the average silhouette method is applied to find the optimal number of clusters. The dataset underlying this analysis comprises more than 4.5 million observations in 380 German regions from 2013 Q1 to 2018 Q4. The clusters are then analysed by means of further economic and socioeconomic data in order to identify similarities. Furthermore, the clusters are interpreted from a geographic perspective. We find that the allocation to cluster 1 is always supported by higher growth rates in the variables, population, working population and real GDP, implying higher demand for space. Moreover, in each of the analysed categories cluster 1 reveals a lower unemployment rate as well as a higher disposable income. One of the most interesting implications is, that apparently a large part of the German population has developed into professional real estate investors. In Germany the largest share of landlords is the one of the so-called non-professional landlords. As the regions assigned to cluster 1, displaying the most significant price increase, seem to be chosen based on a very sophisticated market analysis by identifying the regions with the strongest fundamental data, it seems like the dominating market players have significantly increased their knowledge and approach for investing in residential real estate.

Research article · The Resilient Estate · Real estate & resilience

Exploring the determinants of real estate liquidity from an alternative perspective: censored quantile regression in real estate research

In this paper, the liquidity (inverse of time on market) of rental dwellings and its determinants for different liquidity quantiles are examined for the seven largest German cities. The determinants are estimated using censored quantile regressions in order to investigate the impact on very liquid to very illiquid dwellings. As market heterogeneity is not only observed between cities but also within a city, each of the seven cities is considered individually. Micro data for almost 500,000 observations from 2013 to 2017 is used to examine the time on market. Substantial differences in the magnitude and direction of the regression coefficients for the different liquidity quantiles are found. Furthermore, both the magnitude and direction of the impact of an explanatory variable on the liquidity, differ between the cities. To the best of the authors’ knowledge this is the first paper, to apply censored quantile regressions to liquidity analysis of the real estate rental market. The model reveals that the proportionality assumption underlying the Cox proportional hazards model cannot be confirmed for all variables across all cities, but for most of them.

Research article · The Resilient Estate · Real estate & resilience

Empirical analysis of the illiquidity premia of German real estate securities

In this study, we analyze illiquidity premia and their effect on the expected returns of German real estate securities. To this end, we use a unique data set that includes real estate stocks, real estate investment trusts (REITs), and open- and closed-end real estate funds for 2003–2017. We follow Amihud’s (JFM 5:31–56, 2002) structural approach; specifically, we estimate Amihud’s illiquidity factors, investigate the relationships between expected returns and illiquidity, and analyze the effects of expected and unexpected market illiquidity on future returns. We show that illiquidity plays an important role in expected returns for real estate stocks and investment trusts (REITs); however, it has less clear effects on open- and closed-end funds. We find that the adjusted ILLIQ includes appropriate correction factors for securities with low trading activity and is a useful improvement. We also find evidence of structural breaks in the relationship between returns and illiquidity.

Research article · The Resilient Estate · Real estate & resilience

Asymmetric Patterns of Demand-Supply Mismatch in Real Estate

As expectations change, we may observe asymmetry in responses of economic agents over various phases of the economic cycles. In this paper, we analyze both demand and supply side information to understand the dynamics of price determination in the real estate market and examine the relationship between expectation parameters and demand-supply mismatch. Our hypothesis builds on the possibility that investors’ call for action in terms of their buy/sell decision and adjustment in reservation prices may provide valuable insights into impending demand-supply imbalances in the market. We study several real estate sectors to inform our analysis. The timeframe of our analysis (1995–2010) allows us to observe market dynamics over several economic cycles. We test our hypothesis variously using several measures of market activity within a structural panel VAR framework. Our analysis suggests that investors’ attitude may have substantial and statistically significant feedback effects in price determination. These results indicate noticeable asymmetry in responses during the boom, normal and recessionary periods.

Research article · The Resilient Estate · Real estate & resilience

House Prices and Flood Risk Exposure: An Integration of Hedonic Property Model and Spatial Econometric Analysis

The impact of climate change is devastating in developing countries where flood protection and insurance schemes are limited. Certain parts of Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam are under the constant threat of inundation due to sea-level rise. We integrate the hedonic property model in a difference-in-differences framework and spatial econometric analysis into a single analytical framework to estimate the economic effect of pluvial flooding. We find prices for affected houses were discounted by 9% after a large flood event on 30 September 2017. This research contributes to the existing literature as follows. First, we study the economic impact of pluvial floods, which has received less attention in existing studies where large and irregular floods are their focus. Second, the inclusion of legal status as a control variable accounts for the unique character of the Vietnamese housing market. Third, we also identify the recovery of house prices after the flood event.

Research article · The Resilient Estate · Real estate & resilience

Mandatory climate risk disclosure, housing prices, and credit supply

This paper examines how climate risk transparency influences house prices and credit supply. I contend that inadequate property-level climate risk disclosures induce homebuyers to demand a risk aversion discount on house prices, creating a potential market for lemons. Employing a stacked difference-in-differences design, I find that flood risk disclosure laws, by enhancing dwelling-specific flood risk transparency, raise house prices on average by 7.6%. Results strengthen in states with stricter disclosure requirements. Exploiting within-state heterogeneity and controlling for housing market trends, I find that the effects persist and intensify in regions with higher aggregate exposure to flood risk, greater information frictions, and more attention to climate risks. Conversely, the effectiveness of flood risk disclosure laws attenuates in regions where households are less concerned about climate change. Additionally, less sophisticated lenders extend credit to financially constrained borrowers in response to the laws but experience lower profitability.

Research article · The Resilient Estate · Real estate & resilience

Adjusting to the New Normal: River Flood Risk and the Real Estate Market

Do individuals learn from salient river floods and update their risk perceptions accordingly? We exploit the Western European flood in 2021 to estimate changes in property values across German flood risk regions. Flood-prone areas in proximity to the flood or with higher climate change beliefs experience housing price declines, while we observe no statistically significant effects in other flood risk zones. Our results imply that flood risk discounts in the housing market will not adjust uniformly, which may result in suboptimal capital allocation in areas at risk of future flooding.

Research article · The Resilient Estate · Real estate & resilience

What Drives the Premium for Energy-Efficient Apartments – Green Awareness or Purchasing Power?

We analyze whether lower rents for energy-inefficient apartments reflect tenants’ willingness to pay due to a higher green awareness, purchasing power, or energy consumption costs. Based on a German rental apartment dataset from Q1 2007 to Q1 2019, we use interaction terms for socioeconomic characteristics in a hedonic regression model. We find that rents are lower for apartments with higher energy consumption, even in neighborhoods with lower levels of green awareness. This relationship is stronger in neighborhoods with higher purchasing power, such that communities with low levels of green awareness and high purchasing power show the steepest negative slope for increasing energy consumption (−8.6% from the highest to lowest rating). Thus, the rent-decreasing effect of purchasing power is higher than that of green awareness. Splitting the entire period into smaller windows, we find that the interaction effect of green awareness has emerged in the most recent years (2017–2019). This may be driven by changes in regulation, which have made it easier for tenants to assess the energy consumption before they rent, or by a general increase in green awareness over this period.