empirical qualitative · The Stewardship Question · Family governance & succession
Muneer Bham; Anastacia Mamabolo; Steven Zwane · 2026-02-26 · Acta Commercii
Orientation: Family businesses contribute significantly to economic growth; yet, they face succession-planning challenges stemming from the interplay between family and business dynamics.
empirical configurational · The Stewardship Question · Succession across contexts
José António Porfírio; Tiago Carrilho; Joseph Hassid; Ricardo Rodrigues · 2019-11-10 · Sustainability
Family business succession is a key topic that has attracted considerable attention from researchers, especially in the last decade. Most research, however, is based on case studies with limited applicability and fails to present comparisons across international contexts that highlight differences in succession processes. We apply expectation states theory to analyze a sample of 128 observations in two Southern European countries, Portugal and Greece. We study configurations of successors’ characteristics, family business characteristics, the existence (or absence) of a succession plan, and successors’ motivation to succeed. Our aim is to reveal how these issues affect successors’ perceptions of preparation for succession using fuzzy-set qualitative comparative analysis (fsQCA). Family businesses are a dominant organizational form all over the world, and succession issues are critical for the sustainability of family businesses. Our findings suggest that different configurations of conditions influence successors’ perceptions of preparation for family business succession. Moreover, we verify the influence of cultural differences on these processes. This research helps fill a gap in the literature, showing the role of a set of characteristics in successors’ perceptions of preparation for family business succession. Our conclusions provide insight into the types of policies that can promote successful family business succession.
empirical survey · The Stewardship Question · Family authority & controls
Daniel Magalhães Mucci; Ann Jorissen; Fabio Frezatti; Diógenes de Souza Bido · 2021-02-17 · Sustainability
In most studies, the affiliation of the manager (family-affiliated or non-family affiliated) and supposedly related behavior (agent or steward) is considered the sole antecedent to explain a family business’ (non) professionalization of managerial controls. This paper, based on Luhmann’s new system theory, examines whether a family’s decision premises influence the design of managerial controls in family firms in addition to a manager’s family affiliation status. Using survey data of 135 large and medium-sized Brazilian family firms and testing the hypotheses with SEM, this study provides evidence that a family’s decision premises significantly influence the design of managerial controls in family firms. This study provides evidence that when a family’s intention to transfer the firm to next generation (TGO) is high, more formal controls, as well as controls of a more participative nature are adopted in a family firm. Moreover, the results do not indicate that the level of family involvement in management affects the design of controls in firms with high TGO. The results only showed a significant relationship between a family’s intention to control and influence (FCI) the firm and the absence of participative controls. In addition, these findings also illustrate that each single family-induced decision premise has the potential to explain family firm behavior, since each of the two premises considered in our study is related to a different design of the controls adopted by the family firm.
research · The Stewardship Question · Family office financing & liquidity
Antonia Schickinger; Alexandra Bertschi-Michel; Max P. Leitterstorf; Nadine Kammerlander · 2021-01-29 · Small Business Economics
review · The Stewardship Question · Private equity & venture capital
Douglas Cumming; Satish Kumar; Weng Marc Lim; Nitesh Pandey · 2022-10-04 · Small Business Economics
empirical cross country · The Stewardship Question · Entrepreneurial & angel capital
Viviana Fernandez · 2025-01-02 · Financial Innovation
Recent literature has focused on the venture capital investments of large family firms made through their family offices. However, evidence regarding informal venture capital provided to nascent entrepreneurs by small family businesses is scant. I contribute to the literature by modeling the angel investments of about 30,000 family and non-family business entrepreneurs across 49 countries, who contributed about $64 million to businesses started by other entrepreneurs over a 3-year period. Based on this sample, I conclude that in countries with higher rates of small family businesses, angel investors are likely fewer, and the amounts invested in start-ups are also lower. Furthermore, I conclude that the owners/managers of small family businesses invest comparatively less capital in start-ups, irrespective of family relationships. I infer that this is attributable to the financing preferences of family businesses, which favor the use of internal resources for their continuity and the growth of their family capital.
scoping review · The Stewardship Question · Entrepreneurship through acquisition
Alexander Hoffmann; Dominik K. Kanbach; Stephan Stubner · 2023-05-24 · Management Review Quarterly
Entrepreneurship through acquisition (ETA) is gaining momentum as a viable alternative to starting a company on one’s own. However, despite its growing practical relevance, scholarly work about ETA is scarce and has not been comprehensively reviewed. To address this gap, we conduct a systematic review of entrepreneurship literature by identifying studies that examine ETA and its outcomes. Our review methodology was developed based on established guidelines for systematic reviews and protocols, which informed our scoping review process and analytical approach. Searches were conducted on three electronic databases, and inclusion/exclusion criteria were applied. For inclusion, studies must examine an entrepreneurial perspective in buying into a company. Quantitative and qualitative data were extracted for thematic analysis and descriptive statistics. ETA is an entrepreneurship model with growing appeal and relevance in practice but limited academic evidence. While there is extensive research on leveraged buyouts and family-external succession, evidence specifically on ETA is still lacking. In particular, knowledge about the entrepreneurial intent that makes ETA unique is absent from the evidence base. As ETA gains momentum, entrepreneurs need to understand the unique properties, the various approaches, and the upsides and eventual downsides of acquiring a business instead of starting one from scratch. The present work may serve as a starting point for future research as we scope existing evidence on the archetype of ETA and identify a definition, available models, and a process archetype.
research · The Stewardship Question · Asset allocation & alternatives
Tom Arnold; John H. Earl; Joseph Farizo; David North · 2024-05-20 · Journal of Asset Management
conceptual commentary · The Stewardship Question · Impact measurement
Timo Busch; Peter Bruce-Clark; Jeroen Derwall; Robert Eccles; Tessa Hebb; Andreas Hoepner; Christian Klein; Philipp Krueger; Falko Paetzold; Bert Scholtens; Olaf Weber · 2021-01-11 · SN Business & Economics
Practitioners and academics have been using different terms to describe investments in the sustainability context. The latest inflationary term is impact investments—investments that focus on real-world changes in terms of solving social challenges and/or mitigating ecological degradation. At the core of this definition is an emphasis on transformational changes. However, the term impact investment is often used interchangeably for any investment that incorporates environmental, social, and governance (ESG) aspects. In the latter instance, achieving transformational change is not the main purpose of such investments, which therefore carries the risk of impact washing (akin to “green washing”). To offer (re-)orientation from an academic perspective, we derive a new typology of sustainable investments. This typology delivers a precise definition of what impact investments are and what they should cover. As one central contribution, we propose distinguishing between impact-aligned investments and impact-generating investments. Based on these insights, we hope to lay the foundation for future research and debates in the field of impact investing by practitioners, policymakers, and academics alike.
empirical qualitative · The Stewardship Question · Values & impact governance
Brett R. Smith; Amanda Lawson; Jessica Jones; Tim Holcomb; Aimee Minnich · 2022-06-03 · Journal of Business Ethics
While research has focused on financial and social goals in impact investing, we add to the limited research that focuses on how individuals manage identity multiplicity, defined as three or more role identities. Based on our qualitative study of Christian impact investors, we develop a model of identity multiplicity work, explaining how individuals manage their multiple role identities (financial, social, and religious) to reduce identity tensions during the process of impact investing. We find individuals engaged in an interactive, ongoing three-step process of identity multiplicity work: prioritizing one of their salient identities, managing their identity multiplicity interrelationships, and reinforcing their prioritized identity. Investors generally prioritized an identity that was neither financial nor social, but rather religious. We also find this identity work implemented through three novel mechanisms: shadowing, one identity casts a shadow over another thereby enabling the simultaneous pursuit of related goals; distinguishing, all identities are retained and at least a minimum threshold of role expectations are met; and surrendering, partial sacrificing of goals of one (or more) identity in favor of another identity based on an individual’s self-reflective importance of the role. Our findings offer new insights to multiple identities, impact investing and business ethics literatures.
empirical case study · The Stewardship Question · Investor–enterprise alignment
Anirudh Agrawal; Kai Hockerts · 2019-07-30 · Sustainability
Impact investing pursues the dual goals of creating socio-economic value for the marginalized, and ensuring net positive financial returns. Impact investing firms achieve their goals through their investments in projects and enterprises which create both social and commercial values. The primary aim of this article is to contribute to our understanding of the process of impact investing, particularly with respect to issues related to aligning impact investing and investee social enterprise goals. The research method employs case-based research methodology. The data consist of six cases of impact investing and their investee social enterprises. In addition, the data involve interviews with experts from the field of impact investing. The findings are that: (1) Social mission plays an important moderating role in the inter-organizational relationship between the impact investor and the investee social enterprise, (2) and an emphasis on due diligence, sector specialization, and communication increases the likelihood of investment while (3) social impact measurement and reporting and frequent engagement increase the likelihood of post-investment alignment. The key contribution of this article is that impact investing (unlike venture capital) is influenced by the ability of its investee to create social value, which plays an important role in the inter-organizational relationship between investor and investee. Furthermore, similar to industry specialization in the for-profit investing, social sector specialization is equally relevant for alignment and returns.
practitioner toolkit · The Stewardship Question · Philanthropy & learning
Stanford Center on Philanthropy and Civil Society · 2020 · Stanford PACS · Effective Philanthropy Learning Initiative
A practitioner toolkit from the Stanford Center on Philanthropy and Civil Society for clarifying values, selecting areas of giving, developing a philanthropic strategy and learning from practice.
conceptual legal analysis · The Stewardship Question · Private equity governance & impact
David Birchall; Nadia Bernaz · 2023-03-23 · Human Rights Review
In this article, we apply the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights to the private equity (PE) business model. PE firms often adopt a controversial, ‘value extractive’, business model based on high debt and extreme cost-cutting to generate investor returns. PE firms own large numbers of companies, including in many rights-related sectors. The model is linked to increased human rights risks to workers, housing tenants, and in privatized health and social care. We map these risks and analyse the human rights responsibilities of PE firms. Our analysis has major implications for understandings of human rights responsibility. We argue that value extractive methods are the root cause of eventual harm to human rights, even though they may not harm rights directly. To respect human rights, PE firms must mitigate the risks of these value extractive methods. We define how human rights due diligence (HRDD) could achieve this and argue that given the extent of harm and the lack of a business case for adopting such a view of human rights responsibility, business strategy level HRDD should be a core component of forthcoming HRDD laws.
systematic review · The Stewardship Question · Digital finance & cyber resilience
Olumayowa Adefowope Adekoya; Hany F. Atlam; Harjinder Singh Lallie · 2025-07-11 · Sensors
The increasing frequency and sophistication of cyber attacks have posed significant challenges for digital financial organisations, particularly in quantifying their multidimensional impacts. These challenges are largely attributed to the lack of a standardised cyber impact taxonomy, limited data availability, and the evolving nature of technological threats. As a result, organisations often struggle with ineffective security investment prioritisation, reactive incident response planning, and the inability to implement robust, risk-based controls. Hence, an efficient and comprehensive approach is needed to quantify the diverse impacts of cyber attacks in digital financial services. This paper presents a systematic review and examination of the state of the art in cyber impact quantification, with a particular focus on digital financial organisations. Based on a structured search strategy, 44 articles (out of 637) were selected for in-depth analysis. The review investigates the terminologies used to describe cyber impacts, categorises current quantification techniques (pre-attack and post-attack), and identifies the most commonly utilised internal and external data sources. Furthermore, it explores the application of Machine Learning (ML) and Deep Learning (DL) techniques in cyber security risk quantification. Our findings reveal a significant lack of standardised taxonomy for describing and quantifying the multidimensional impact of cyberattacks across physical, digital, economic, psychological, reputational, and societal dimensions. Lastly, open issues and future research directions are discussed. This work provides insights for researchers and professionals by consolidating and identifying quantification technique gaps in cyber security risk quantification.Keywords: risk quantification, impact quantification, taxonomy, cyber security impact, multidimensional impact, digital financial service, machine learning, deep learning
Research article · Women Who Shape Wealth · Succession, legitimacy & leadership
Kathy K. Overbeke; Diana Bilimoria; Toni Somers · 2015-05-29 · Frontiers in Psychology
Family businesses are critical to the United States economy, employing 63% of the workforce and generating 57% of GDP (University of Vermont, 2014). Family business continuity, however, remains elusive as approximately 70% of family businesses do not survive the second generation (Poza, 2013). In order to augment our understanding of how next generation leaders are chosen in family businesses, we examine daughter succession. Using a sample of pairs of family business fathers and daughters and drawing on an earlier study of the dearth of successor daughters in family businesses (Overbeke et al., 2013), we reveal that shared vision between fathers and daughters is central to daughter succession. Self-efficacy and gender norms influence shared vision and when fathers and daughters share a vision for the future of the company, daughters are likely to be transformed into successors.
Research article · Women Who Shape Wealth · Succession, legitimacy & leadership
Manuel Feldmann; Martin Lukes; Lorraine Uhlaner · 2020-11-21 · Small Business Economics
This study adapts a multi-level view of culture, including society- and family-based gender norms and the family embeddedness perspective, to predict the career status of a sample of 2897 young Europeans (aged 18–35) from 11 countries, with at least one self-employed parent. We find that gender identity is associated with career status such that a woman is more likely than a man to be an employee vs. a successor to a family firm but no less likely to be a founder as compared with either being an employee or successor. However, certain family and society-level culture variables combined with gender identity reverse these trends. A woman with caring responsibilities is more likely to be a successor than either a founder or employee. Also, while two-way interaction effects for traditional gender norms and having a self-employed mother are weak or not significant, the study finds that in combination, a woman reporting both traditional gender norms and having a self-employed mother is more likely to be a successor than being either an employee or a founder, reversing gender identity main effects. Incorporating the family embeddedness perspective and the role of culture in occupational choice, we develop a better view of the gender gap in entrepreneurship, finding that the family may serve as a stronger influence than society when implied norms of these two levels of culture clash. By examining actual rather than intended career choice, we also contribute to the occupational choice literature on youth employment.
Research article · Women Who Shape Wealth · Succession, legitimacy & leadership
Angel L. Meroño-Cerdán · 2022-03-05 · Journal of Family and Economic Issues
Female managers are more common in family firms largely due to women’s incorporation into management positions via succession. Nonetheless, extrinsic and intrinsic factors constrain to some extent the access and the outcomes of female managers as potential successors. This study aims to uncover the particular conditions under which women frequently have access to CEO positions in family firms. Using a database of 177 SME Spanish family firms and using cluster analysis based on TwoStep technique, women are found to be unexpected successors to a greater extent than male successors. Oftentimes, they are chosen as a last resort to cope with poor business performance and low family orientation. More than an opportunity, this unplanned access becomes a trap since it fails to comply with all the requirements of successful transmissions.
Qualitative short report · Women Who Shape Wealth · Succession, legitimacy & leadership
Kyriakos Lingas · 2013-05-21 · Journal of Innovation and Entrepreneurship
Economy, business, and entrepreneurship are related to the world of men. Home, nurturing, and the family belong to women's world, so the story goes. On the other hand, family entrepreneurship and its outcome, the family business, is probably the most traditional way of conducting business, being thus a universal phenomenon. However, in comparison to other economic and entrepreneurial activities, the field of family entrepreneurship has been only recently addressed by economists, researchers, and academicians. Family entrepreneurship as a field of inquiry is suffering the consequences of conceptual dualisms rendering ‘family’ and ‘business’, ‘kinship’ and ‘economy,’ ‘private,’ and ‘public’ as distinct social and economic spheres. To that extent, the topic lies at the ‘gray zones’ of scholarly inquiry, resisting clear-cut definitions and approaches.
Research article · Women Who Shape Wealth · Succession, legitimacy & leadership
Lisa K. Gundry; Jill R. Kickul; Tatiana Iakovleva; Alan L. Carsrud · 2014-03-26 · Journal of Innovation and Entrepreneurship
This research presents an examination of familial influence on strategic entrepreneurial behaviors within a transitional economic context. Utilizing a large sample of women-led family businesses, the study investigates the relationships between risk-taking propensity, entrepreneurial intensity, and opportunity recognition of the entrepreneur and the innovative orientation of the firm and sustainability. A model of the influences on innovativeness and sustainability in family firms is developed, and the potential contribution of the present study is the identification of constructs that facilitate these strategic outcomes and behaviors that drive growth. The degree to which family firms can create new products, services, and processes that add value to their marketplace can strongly influence their sustainability, especially in an emerging economy.
Research article · Women Who Shape Wealth · Succession, legitimacy & leadership
Huiping Xian; Nan Jiang; Maura McAdam · 2020-10-08 · International Small Business Journal
This article explores the approaches of identity construction used by Chinese daughters while negotiating the successor–leader role within family businesses. A qualitative interpretivist approach was adopted to understand daughter views on gender, family business leadership and succession, as well as the approaches adopted to negotiate the role of female successor/leader in the Chinese family business. Twenty semi-structured interviews were conducted with both actual and potential female successors. Three approaches of identity construction emerged based on the degree of conformity to traditional gender roles and Confucian family values: first, to abide by conventional gender expectations and perceive themselves as a temporary leader; second, to act as the ‘second leader’ and remain involved in decision making and third, to challenge conventional gender roles and strive to be an independent leader. This article contributes to debates on women in family business and gendered identity construction of daughters in family business in the Chinese context.