Journal DOI 10.68956/journal.family-office-private-wealth

Journal Opal · Research guides

Read the source.
Ask its paper.

Search attributed records and open each reading agent. Original publication details, rights and evidence coverage remain on the individual paper.

Research article · Capital with Conviction · Private capital & investment governance

Drivers of Philanthropic Foundations in Emerging Markets: Family, Values and Spirituality

This article discusses the ethics and drivers of philanthropic foundations in emerging markets. A foundation organizes assets to invest in philanthropic initiatives. Previous scholarship has largely focused on developed countries, especially the United States, and has questioned the ethics behind the activities of foundations, particularly for strategic motives that served wider corporate purposes. We argue that philanthropic foundations in emerging markets have distinctive characteristics that merit separate examination. We scrutinize the ethics behind the longitudinal activity of such foundations using 70 oral history interviews with business leaders in 18 countries in Africa, Asia, Latin America, and the Middle East. We find that 55 out of 70 foundations associated with these leaders have been used as vehicles for a specific type of philanthropic ethics defined as “spiritual philanthropy”. These foundations often embodied personal or family traditions, culture, and religious values, which emphasized charitable giving and social responsibility. As in the case of many of the industrial foundations in Europe, these foundations also carried founding family names and provided a structure to maintain family control and enhance corporate reputation. We argue that, as business leaders in emerging markets are more directly exposed to dire social, educational and health deprivation than their counterparts in developed countries, they are less inclined toward grandiose world-making, and their foundations are more focused on delivering immediate benefits to communities in their home countries, motivated by implicit or explicit spirituality.

Research article · Capital with Conviction · Private capital & investment governance

How Billionaires Explain Their Philanthropy: A Mixed-Method Analysis of the Giving Pledge Letters

This study investigates a discourse about billionaire philanthropy established in letters submitted by 187 of 209 signatories of the Giving Pledge. The philanthropy of the wealthy is gaining increasing public attention and is subject to growing criticism, which demands additional study of how the wealthy collectively explain their generosity. The mixed-method analysis finds a strong emphasis on education and health causes and identifies two distinct and coherent rationales for being generous. The majority of letters express a social–normative rationale, consisting of two prevailing explanations: an expressed gratitude and desire to “give back” (1) and references to family upbringing as a socializing force (2). A minority of letters articulate a personal–consequentialist rationale, highlighting three separate explanations: a large inheritance may harm offspring (1), giving as personal gratification (2), and an acknowledgment of excess wealth with no better use (3). An expressed desire to have impact and make a difference appears in both rationales. The overall dominance of a social–normative rationale projects a discourse emphasizing benevolence as well as a narrative in which billionaires are an exceptionally productive and grateful subset of society. While previous studies have primarily focused on identifying individual psychological motives, this study shows how the Giving Pledge letters reflect a philanthropic discourse among the wealthy going back to Andrew Carnegie’s Gospel of Wealth .

Research article · Capital with Conviction · Private capital & investment governance

Do ESG funds make stakeholder-friendly investments?

Investment funds that claim to focus on socially responsible stocks have proliferated in recent times. In this paper, we verify whether ESG mutual funds actually invest in firms that have stakeholder-friendly track records. Using a comprehensive sample of self-labelled ESG mutual funds (as identified by Morningstar) in the United States from 2010 to 2018, we find that these funds hold portfolio firms with worse track records for compliance with labor and environmental laws, relative to portfolio firms held by non-ESG funds managed by the same financial institutions in the same years. Relative to other funds offered by the same asset managers in the same years, ESG funds hold stocks that are more likely to voluntarily disclose carbon emissions performance but also stocks with higher carbon emissions per unit of revenue. Despite these findings, ESG funds hold portfolio firms with higher average ESG scores. We show that ESG scores are correlated with the quantity of voluntary ESG-related disclosures but not with firms’ compliance records or actual levels of carbon emissions. Finally, ESG funds appear to underperform financially relative to other funds within the same asset manager and year, and to charge higher fees. Our findings suggest that socially responsible funds do not appear to follow through on proclamations of concerns for stakeholders.

Research article · Capital with Conviction · Private capital & investment governance

How does philanthropy influence the diffusion of knowledge? Impacts from donations on scientific publications and patents in STEM

Interest in philanthropy has witnessed a resurgence in recent decades, paralleled by a steep increase in the creation of individual fortunes. Originally being a more conspicuous phenomenon in Anglo-Saxon countries, philanthropy has become increasingly salient in traditional welfare states. However, the economic implications of philanthropy basically remain unknown. Here, we examine whether donations to research at higher education institutes (HEIs) in Sweden affect their knowledge output, as reflected in scientific publications and patent applications. The analysis is confined to the STEM-disciplines (science, technology, engineering, and mathematics) for the period 2001 to 2015. We have access to data on the respective HEIs’ total research funding for STEM divided into donations, corporations, public block grants, and other public sources. In the analysis, we compare the effects of different research funding on knowledge output relative to their base funding. Implementing numerous controls, we find that patent applications are positively associated with a higher regional share of donations, whereas no such effects are detected for scientific publications. This is indicative of philanthropy being positively related to growth, since contemporary microeconomic models assign a critical role to innovation in promoting growth and societal prosperity.

Research article · The Resilient Estate · Real estate & resilience

Estimating the Flood Risk Discount: Evidence From a One-off National Information Shock

Flood risk is a highly pervasive and costly natural hazard globally. With significant increases in flood risk expected over coming decades, future exposure to flood risk and associated costs will depend heavily on how private consumption decisions respond to new information about risk. We exploit a one-off national information treatment in the form of the release in 2011, for the first time, of detailed flood risk maps for Ireland, to test the effect of new information about flood risk on housing prices across a national housing market. We combine rich dwelling-level information on over 475,000 dwellings for the period 2006-2015 with detailed official data relating to flood risk, events and defences. Our core finding is that information matters. The price of housing responded clearly to the release of flood risk maps at the end of 2011, with the emergence of a 4% price discount for dwellings at risk of flooding.

Research article · laboratory experiment · Who Holds the Pen? · Governance & succession

Charitable giving: The role of framing and information

We investigate how different levels of information influence the allocation decisions of donors who are entitled to freely distribute a fixed monetary endowment between themselves and a charitable organization in both giving and taking frames. Participants donate significantly higher amounts, when the decision is described as taking rather than giving. This framing effect becomes smaller if more information about the charity is provided.

Peer-reviewed experimental research article · Who Holds the Pen? · Governance & succession

Sure-thing vs. probabilistic charitable giving: Experimental evidence on the role of individual differences in risky and ambiguous charitable decision-making

Charities differ, among other things, alongside the likelihood that their interventions succeed and produce the desired outcomes and alongside the extent that such likelihood can even be articulated numerically. In this paper, we investigate what best explains charitable giving behaviour regarding charities that have interventions that will succeed with a quantifiable and high probability (sure-thing charities) and charities that have interventions that only have a small and hard to quantify probability of bringing about the desired end (probabilistic charities). We study individual differences in risk/ambiguity attitudes, empathy, numeracy, optimism, and donor type (warm glow vs. pure altruistic donor type) as potential predictors of this choice. We conduct a money incentivised, pre-registered experiment on Prolific on a representative UK sample (n = 1,506) to investigate participant choices (i) between these two types of charities and (ii) about one randomly selected charity. Overall, we find little to no evidence that individual differences predict choices regarding decisions about sure-thing and probabilistic charities, with the exception that a purely altruistic donor type predicts donations to probabilistic charities when participants were presented with a randomly selected charity in (ii). Conducting exploratory equivalence tests, we find that the data provide robust evidence in favour of the absence of an effect (or a negligibly small effect) where we fail to reject the null. This is corroborated by exploratory Bayesian analyses. We take this paper to be contributing to the literature on charitable giving via this comprehensive null-result in pursuit of contributing to a cumulative science.

Research article · observational CEO surveys and external validation · Who Holds the Pen? · Governance & succession

Are chief executive officers more likely to be first-borns?

We investigate the link between birth order and the career outcome of becoming Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of a company. CEOs are more likely to be the first-born, i.e., oldest, child of their family relative to what one would expect if birth order did not matter for career outcomes. Both male and female CEOs are more likely to be first-born. However, the first-born advantage seems to largely reflect the absence of an older brother, but not of an older sister. These results are more pronounced for family firms, where traditionally the oldest child is appointed to run the family business, but also hold for non-family firms.

Research article · randomized field experiment · Who Holds the Pen? · Governance & succession

Agentic appeals increase charitable giving in an affluent sample of donors

Recent research suggests that affluent individuals adopt agentic self-concepts, striving to stand out from others and to master the environment on their own. The present study provides a road test of this idea, showing that this theorizing can be utilized to increase charitable giving among the affluent, when individuals do not realize that their behavior is being studied. In a naturalistic field experiment conducted as part of an annual fundraising campaign (N = 12,316), we randomly assigned individuals from an affluent sample to view messages focused on agency (vs. communion). Messages that focused on personal agency (vs. communion) increased the total amount of money that individuals in the sample donated by approximately 82%. These findings provide evidence for a simple, theoretically-grounded method of encouraging donations among those with the greatest capacity to give.

Research article · randomized online experiment · Intelligence with Judgment · Intelligence, trust & financial decisions

Putting a human in the loop: Increasing uptake, but decreasing accuracy of automated decision-making

Automated decision-making gains traction, prompting discussions on regulation with calls for human oversight. Understanding how human involvement affects the acceptance of algorithmic recommendations and the accuracy of resulting decisions is vital. In an online experiment (N = 292), for a prediction task, participants choose a recommendation stemming either from an algorithm or another participant. In a between-subject design, we varied if the prediction was delegated completely or if the recommendation could be adjusted. 66% of times, participants preferred to delegate the decision to an algorithm over an equally accurate human. The preference for an algorithm increased by 7 percentage points if participants could monitor and adjust the recommendations. Participants followed algorithmic recommendations more closely. Importantly, they were less likely to intervene with the least accurate recommendations. Hence, in our experiment the human-in-the-loop design increases the uptake but decreases the accuracy of the decisions.

Research article · observational panel study · Who Holds the Pen? · Governance & succession

Why do family firms dismiss their family CEOs? A perspective on kinship ties

Existing studies have suggested that nonfamily CEOs are more likely to be fired from family firms, while we focus on why family CEOs are also fired from family firms. Using data from 455 listed Chinese family firms, we find that family CEOs with affinity ties are more likely to be dismissed as they are not genetically related to the family. The difference becomes greater when firm performance is poor or family ownership is high. These findings elaborate that business-owing family is not a group with aligned interests, that is, family members with different family identities are treated differently within family. Besides, existing studies have emphasized that the preservation of socioemotional wealth in family firms can affect firms’ operations, while this study further proposes that the preservation of socioemotional wealth can also have an impact on the business-owning families themselves.

Research article · Who Holds the Pen? · Governance & succession

Internationalization of family firms on innovation: Moderating impact of socioemotional wealth and institutional environment

Currently, there is a lack of research specifically investigating the influence of internationalization on the innovation of family firms. This paper aims to investigate the influence of both internationalization depth and breadth on the innovation of family firms. Additionally, it aims to analyze how socioemotional wealth (SEW) and regional institutional environment in the home country influence this relationship. To test the hypotheses, a questionnaire survey was carried out with a sample of 253 family firms situated in eight provinces or municipalities in China. The results are as follows: First, internationalization depth negatively influenced family firm innovation, whereas internationalization breadth positively influenced family firm innovation. Second, the negative influence of internationalization depth on innovation was pronounced at a high level of family control, whereas the positive influence of internationalization breadth on innovation was pronounced at a low level of transgenerational succession intention in family firms. Third, a well-developed institutional environment strengthened the relationship between internationalization and innovation in family firms. This research enriches the literature on internationalization and innovation in family firms, and offers useful insights for practitioners.

Research article · Who Holds the Pen? · Governance & succession

The impact of de-familization on green innovation: Evidence from SRDI family firms in China

Green innovation is essential for sustainable development, especially in China’s Specialized-Refined-Differentiated-Innovative (SRDI) enterprises. Family-owned SRDI firms, in particular, have attracted attention due to their de-familization strategies and their influence on green innovation. Our study analyzes panel data from 2016 to 2021 for listed SRDI family firms to investigate how de-familization in management rights and ownership impacts green innovation. Using socio-emotional wealth (SEW) theory and a fixed-effects model, we find that de-familization significantly negatively affects green innovation, with corporate governance serving as a mediating factor. Digital transformation moderates these negative effects, while market concentration exacerbates them. These impacts are more pronounced in firms before being designated as "Little Giants," those receiving higher government subsidies, those located in eastern regions, or those not classified as major polluters. This research provides actionable insights for SRDI family firms to strategically manage de-familization, optimize resource allocation, implement customized governance strategies, and promote sustainable growth.

Research article · Who Holds the Pen? · Governance & succession

CEO social capital and implied cost of capital: Based on the empirical evidence of Chinese family businesses

Social capital plays a crucial role in resource integration within Chinese family businesses. This research investigates the relationship between CEO social capital and the implied cost of capital, while also considering the influence of CEO type on this relationship. The empirical results based on China’s A-share family-listed companies show that CEO social capital helps to reduce the implied capital cost of family business. However, compared with non-family CEO, the effect of family CEO social capital on reducing the implied cost of capital is weaker. The mechanism analysis confirms that CEO social capital reduces the implied cost of capital through reducing corporate risk and improving information transparency. The heterogeneity analysis reveals that CEO social capital significantly reduces the implicit cost of capital only in entrepreneurial families, companies with low family control, and those without intergenerational transmission. Additionally, the effect of CEO social capital is more pronounced in fiercely competitive markets and high-tech industries. When economic policy uncertainty is high and investor legal protections are weak, CEO social capital can better exert its complementary effect on formal institutions. These findings not only provide a theoretical foundation for leveraging the informal system of social capital to strengthen family governance but also offer practical insights for addressing the classic decision of whether to choose family succession or hire professional managers.

Research article · Who Holds the Pen? · Governance & succession

Earmarking donations to boost study participation? Evidence from a field experiment

Charitable donations are often the most suitable available way to incentivize study participation, yet their optimal design remains unclear. In a preregistered field experiment, we invited 6,711 psychology faculty at top-200 universities to complete a survey in exchange for a US $5 donation to test whether allowing prospective participants to earmark the donation for a specific purpose increases study participation. Contrary to preregistered hypotheses derived from previous literature, the results showed no significant increase in study participation rates when participants could earmark their donation compared to a random allocation of funds. These findings suggest that while earmarking has been shown to enhance overall donation rates, its effectiveness may not extend to incentivizing study participation.

Research article · Who Holds the Pen? · Governance & succession

Ownership succession, risk taking and debt financing from the perspective of the institutional environment

This study examines family firms listed on China’s A-share market, using a two-way fixed effects model to explore the impact of ownership succession on debt financing and the moderating role of the institutional environment. The findings indicate that second-generation ownership succession reduces risk-taking, which in turn lowers debt financing. Additionally, the institutional environment mitigates the negative relationship between second-generation ownership succession, risk-taking, and debt financing. Further analysis reveals that factors such as the development of the non-state-owned economy, the maturity of factor markets, and advancements in market intermediaries and legal systems significantly moderate these relationships. This study broadens the research perspective on intergenerational succession in family businesses and offers empirical insights to help family firms adapt to regional institutional differences more effectively.

Research article · Who Holds the Pen? · Governance & succession

How to observe business operations: An empirical study of family business

The direct observation method is commonly used for data collection in family business case studies. Nevertheless, in research on family business succession that is mainly based on retrospective data, it is difficult to directly observe an event or situation at a given time. This paper thus first explores the application of observation data in the published research results of some family business case studies through a literature review. It then describes our observation methodology, i.e., sampling process, method, observation process, and reevaluation of our interview data, through a case study. Finally, the conclusion offers suggestions for using these observation methods, i.e., employing different types of observation, by considering running time and financial cost, familiarizing observers with various observation occasions, and seeking the assistance of relevant professionals for a research topic.

Research article · Who Holds the Pen? · Governance & succession

Investor attention and corporate social responsibility of family businesses in Vietnam: The moderating role of CEO overpower

This study examines the influence of investor attention and Chief Executive Officers (CEOs) power on Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) within Vietnamese family businesses. Unlike most of the past literature, this study further investigates the potential moderating effects of CEOs’ power on the relationship between investor attention and CSR. Utilizing the dynamic system Generalized Method of Moments (GMM), this study analyzes a dataset comprising 116 Vietnamese family businesses from 2005 to 2020. The findings reveal an inverted U-shape between CEO power and CSR within family businesses; meanwhile, investor attention demonstrates a negative impact on CSR. Moreover, the results report that CEO power is a moderating factor in the relationship between investor attention and CSR. These results are consistent with various theoretical frameworks, including agency theory, overinvestment, career concern, career horizon, and conflict-resolution hypotheses. Finally, our study offers management implications to foster the sustainable development of CSR within family businesses, particularly within emerging markets.

Research article · Who Holds the Pen? · Governance & succession

The influence of non-family members in top management teams on research and development investment: Evidence from Chinese family firms

The diversified management ability of the non-family members in the top management teams (TMTs) can significantly increase the research and development (R&D) investment of the family firms. However, existing studies focus on family characteristics. To bridge the gap, this study explored the R&D investment propensity for family firms from the perspective of non-family members’ participation in TMTs. Based on the upper echelons and the socioemotional wealth theory, this paper incorporated the non-economic goals that influence strategic decisions on family firms into the analytical framework. According to the questionnaire data of Chinese private enterprises, the Tobit regression model was used to analyze the influence of family members on R&D investment decisions under non-economic goal orientations. The results indicated that the preference for control and influence among family members weakens the positive effect of non-family managers on R&D investment, while the preferences for status perception and social responsibility strengthen the positive effect.

Research article · Who Holds the Pen? · Governance & succession

Mental Imagery, Impact, and Affect: A Mediation Model for Charitable Giving

One of the puzzling phenomena in philanthropy is that people can show strong compassion for identified individual victims but remain unmoved by catastrophes that affect large numbers of victims. Two prominent findings in research on charitable giving reflect this idiosyncrasy: The (1) identified victim and (2) victim number effects. The first of these suggests that identifying victims increases donations and the second refers to the finding that people’s willingness to donate often decreases as the number of victims increases. While these effects have been documented in the literature, their underlying psychological processes need further study. We propose a model in which identified victim and victim number effects operate through different cognitive and affective mechanisms. In two experiments we present empirical evidence for such a model and show that different affective motivations (donor-focused vs. victim-focused feelings) are related to the cognitive processes of impact judgments and mental imagery. Moreover, we argue that different mediation pathways exist for identifiability and victim number effects.