Research article · Women Who Shape Wealth · Board authority & accountable ownership
Ana Beatriz Hernández-Lara; Juan Pablo Gonzales-Bustos; Amado Alarcón-Alarcón · 2021-02-12 · Sustainability
There is growing institutional and social pressure for greater balance, parity, and equality at the highest levels of corporations. This is coupled with an increasing interest in analysing the effects of gender diversity on corporate boards. However, companies may only reap the benefits of gender diversity by achieving better qualified and more independent boards. This study aims to contribute to the open debate on the effects of board gender diversity on R&D, by taking into account the independence of female directors. Panel regression analyses were performed with data for 67 Spanish-listed companies during the 2003–2019 period. Our results confirm the positive effects of gender diversity on R&D. However, this positive influence is lower if female directors have family links with male members on the board. These findings have policy implications, regarding the need to increase gender equality in corporate boards for social and sustainability purposes, while the benefits are conditioned by the independence of female directors. The value of this research rests on the study of the effects, beyond the mere analysis of financial performance of the gender diversity of boards.
Research article · Women Who Shape Wealth · Board authority & accountable ownership
Emma García-Meca; Domingo J. Santana-Martín · 2022-07-11 · Review of Managerial Science
Using a sample of 1134 firm-year observations of non-financial family firms listed on the Spanish stock market in the period 2003–2020, we explore how women directors affect company performance, distinguishing between family and non-family female members on the board. We believe there might be faultlines between family and non-family women on boards that may well impair performance due to differences in agency conflicts and socioemotional links with the family firm. As the number of female family directors grows, we reveal that conflicts with non-family sub-groups become more prevalent, impairing firm performance. Opening boards to non-family women does, however, seem to be an effective way of enhancing firm performance when there is a critical mass of female directors. The results are robust to alternative measures of board gender diversity and different econometric specifications.
Research article · Women Who Shape Wealth · Board authority & accountable ownership
Maximiliano González; Alexander Guzmán; Eduardo Pablo; María Andrea Trujillo · 2018-07-10 · Review of Managerial Science
In this study, using a unique hand-collected sample of 523 closely held Colombian family firms and 5.094 firm-year observations, with 4907 board members, including 833 female board members, we show that female directors have a negative effect on firm performance. However, when we separate female directors into two groups, family female directors and outside female directors, we find that the latter has a positive and significant effect on firm performance. We further construct a human capital index after a detailed analysis of 15% of the total curriculum vitae of directors for those in our sample we were able to find. Although the subsample is not representative enough to make general claims for the whole sample due to data constraints, we shed some light about a potential gender bias in the development of the human capital of heirs and the corresponding impact of different levels of directors’ education and experience on firms’ financial performance.
Review article · Women Who Shape Wealth · Board authority & accountable ownership
Jan Luca Pletzer; Romina Nikolova; Karina Karolina Kedzior; Sven Constantin Voelpel · 2015-06-18 · PLOS ONE
In recent years, there has been an ongoing, worldwide debate about the representation of females in companies. Our study aimed to meta-analytically investigate the controversial relationship between female representation on corporate boards and firm financial performance. Following a systematic literature search, data from 20 studies on 3097 companies published in peer-reviewed academic journals were included in the meta-analysis. On average, the boards consisted of eight members and female participation was low (mean 14%) in all studies. Half of the 20 studies were based on data from developing countries and 62% from higher income countries. According to the random-effects model, the overall mean weighted correlation between percentage of females on corporate boards and firm performance was small and non-significant (r = .01, 95% confidence interval: -.04, .07). Similar small effect sizes were observed when comparing studies based on developing vs. developed countries and higher vs. lower income countries. The mean board size was not related to the effect sizes in studies. These results indicate that the mere representation of females on corporate boards is not related to firm financial performance if other factors are not considered. We conclude our study with a discussion of its implications and limitations. Citation: Pletzer JL, Nikolova R, Kedzior KK, Voelpel SC (2015) Does Gender Matter? Female Representation on Corporate Boards and Firm Financial Performance - A Meta-Analysis. PLoS ONE 10(6): e0130005. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0130005 Academic Editor: Rodrigo Huerta-Quintanilla, Cinvestav-Merida, MEXICO Received: February 3, 2015; Accepted: May 15, 2015; Published: June 18, 2015 Copyright: © 2015 Pletzer et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper (Table 2). Funding: The authors received no specific funding for this work. Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Research article · Women Who Shape Wealth · Board authority & accountable ownership
Pattanaporn Chatjuthamard; Pornsit Jiraporn; Sang Mook Lee · 2021-10-11 · PLOS ONE
We investigate the effect of board gender diversity on managerial risk-taking incentives. Our results demonstrate that companies with stronger board gender diversity provide more powerful executive risk-taking incentives. It appears that female directors’ risk aversion exacerbates managers’ risk aversion, resulting in a sub-optimal level of risk-taking. To offset this tendency for too little risk, companies are induced to provide stronger risk-taking incentives. Specifically, an increase in board gender diversity by one standard deviation raises vega by 10.3%. Further analysis corroborates the results, including propensity score matching, entropy balancing, and an instrumental-variable analysis. Endogeneity appears to be unlikely, suggesting that female directors are not merely associated with, but probably bring about stronger risk-taking incentives. Citation: Chatjuthamard P, Jiraporn P, Lee SM (2021) Does board gender diversity weaken or strengthen executive risk-taking incentives? PLoS ONE 16(10): e0258163. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0258163 Editor: Stefan Cristian Gherghina, The Bucharest University of Economic Studies, ROMANIA Received: June 4, 2021; Accepted: September 21, 2021; Published: October 11, 2021 Copyright: © 2021 Chatjuthamard et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. Data Availability: The data are available through the databases described in the paper. Anyone can access the data with a simple subscription to the database. For instance, our data on firm characteristics are from COMPUSTAT. Anyone with a subscription to COMPUSTAT would have access to the same data we did. COMPUSTAT is offered by S&P. So, one can contact S&P directly to request a subscription (https://www.spglobal.com/marketintelligence/en/?product=compustat-research-insight). A subscription is also available through the Wharton Research Data Service (WRDS) (https://wrds-www.wharton.upenn.edu/). We do not have any special privileges beyond a simple subscription. Funding: The research was funded by Chulalongkorn University under the Ratchadapisek Sompoch Endowment Fund through Center of Excellence (CE) in Management Research for Corporate Governance and Behavioral Finance and Sasin School of Management through SASIN Major Grant for a research program.The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Systematic literature review · Women Who Shape Wealth · Access to private capital
Kevin Koziol; Maja Schmitz; Suleika Bort · 2025-01-16 · Small Business Economics
A growing body of literature explores whether and why female and male entrepreneurs differ in their access to equity financing. This trend has led to an increasing fragmentation of the research field, as many studies analyze various mechanisms and focus on a certain form of equity financing. To advance research on gender differences in equity financing, it is necessary to identify patterns and inconsistent findings in the literature related to these mechanisms. Therefore, we perform a systematic literature review to provide an overview of the current state of knowledge on gender differences in the key forms of entrepreneurial equity financing (venture capital, angel investment, and equity crowdfunding). Based on 75 studies from 2001 to mid-2024, our review indicates that male entrepreneurs have an advantage in raising capital from venture capitalists and business angels, whereas female entrepreneurs are more successful in equity crowdfunding. These gender differences stem from a complex combination of mechanisms, which we categorize into four thematic dimensions that capture entrepreneurs’ characteristics, investors’ characteristics, the ventures’ characteristics and strategies, and contextual factors. We propose specific future research directions for each dimension, and discuss theoretical and methodological research opportunities that are applicable across dimensions to improve our understanding of gender differences in equity financing.
Qualitative content analysis · Women Who Shape Wealth · Access to private capital
Barbara Orser; Susan Coleman; Yanhong Li · 2019-11-29 · Small Business Economics
This paper examines the positioning of gender within women-focused capital funds (WFCFs) to consider the extent to which these digitally enabled sources of finance reflect the tenets of entrepreneurial feminism. Content analysis of 27 funds situated in Canada and the USA informs about fund mandates, rationales, types of capital, and anticipated outcomes. Our findings reveal that a minority of WFCFs examined sought to enhance equity and counter structural barriers associated with women entrepreneurs’ access to financial capital. Alternatively, the majority of WFCFs were positioned as vehicles to facilitate individual wealth creation. Eligibility ranged from multiple gender identities of the business owner to “women-led” businesses—defined as at least one woman executive, board or steering committee member. The latter of these criteria has the effect of diverting attention away from firms that are launched by women entrepreneurs. Pinkwashing was more likely to occur when WFCFs were created as add-ons to mainstream programs and services, rather than as a central element of the organization’s mission of supporting women and non-binary femmes. The findings support arguments that technology can both challenge or reinforce structural constraints that impede women entrepreneurs in the digital era.
Empirical observational study · Women Who Shape Wealth · Access to private capital
Livia Boerner; Thomas Fritz; Bernd Frick · 2024-10-02 · Journal of Business Economics
The high-risk decision environment and information asymmetries associated with investing in early-stage startups in pitch competitions make angel investors prone to biased decision-making. Drawing from social perception theory, this study examines how angel investors’ decisions are influenced by observed personal characteristics of entrepreneurial teams, based on representative stereotypes. Analyzing a dataset of N = 553 startup pitches from the German televised competition Die Höhle der Löwen, this study reveals that the likelihood of securing deals with German angel investors and the resulting business valuations are linked to certain superficial team characteristics. Specifically, the age, diverse ethnicity, and physical attractiveness of the entrepreneurial team have a significant positive effect on deal probabilities. Moreover, angel investors offer lower deal valuations to teams of older and female entrepreneurs, suggesting the presence of a systematic bias. These insights contribute to understanding the role of stereotypes in entrepreneurial finance and address the challenges related to bias in access to capital for early-stage startups in Germany.
Empirical observational study · Women Who Shape Wealth · Access to private capital
Simon Kleinert; Kazem Mochkabadi · 2021-10-11 · The Journal of Technology Transfer
Equity crowdfunding has the potential to democratize entrepreneurial finance and provide female entrepreneurs with new and equal access to early-stage financing. In this paper, we present first empirical evidence on gender stereotypes in the context of technology ventures in equity crowdfunding. Drawing on signaling and gender role congruity theory, we hypothesize that quality signals have different effects depending on whether they are sent by male or female entrepreneurs. Results taken from a sample of 263 equity crowdfunding campaigns run by technology ventures confirm our hypotheses. In line with gender stereotypes, management experience is beneficial for male entrepreneurs but detrimental for female entrepreneurs. Interestingly, media coverage as a third-party signal has the oppositive effect, being more effective for female entrepreneurs.
Empirical observational study · Women Who Shape Wealth · Access to private capital
Udichibarna Bose; Stefano Filomeni; Elena Tabacco · 2024-09-24 · Journal of Business Ethics
Gender bias in leadership and decision-making is a well-documented and pervasive topic that continues to garner significant attention in academic research and business literature. In this paper, by exploiting a unique proprietary dataset of 550 mid-corporate loan applications managed by a major European bank, we explore how the use of soft information influences lending decisions of female loan officers as compared to their male counterparts. We find that use of soft information reduces information asymmetry which helps female officers in making diligent lending decisions resulting in increased granted credit with a lower default probability. We also investigate gender affinity within the banking organisation and find that female loan approvers are more likely to be supportive of their subordinate female loan officers by approving more credit to the loan applications handled by female loan officers. Finally, we examine the possible mechanisms that can explain these results, and find that female loan officers are able to better collect and use soft information as they cultivate and maintain deeper firm-bank relationships with their clients due to higher threat of losing or being penalized in their jobs for any possible errors. We also rule out any other possible explanations such as differences in workload, work experience, loan officers’ optimism, managerial ability, and screening capabilities between female and male loan officers. Our findings carry important policy implications, reflected in the optimal allocation of capital in the economy and the reduction of gender-related exclusion, which is vital in creating an equitable society and fostering a more ethical and inclusive workplace.
Meta-analysis · Women Who Shape Wealth · Access to private capital
Malin Malmström; Barbara Burkhard; Charlotta Sirén; Dean Shepherd; Joakim Wincent · 2023-10-17 · Journal of Business Ethics
This meta-analysis of 31 studies over 20 years advances our understanding of the gender gap in entrepreneurial bank finance. Findings from previous research on the relationship between entrepreneurs’ gender and bank financing are mixed, which suggests the need to pay particular attention to entrepreneurs’ social context. In this study, we develop a model of how social gender norms explain variation in women entrepreneurs’ (vis-à-vis men entrepreneurs’) access to bank finance. Specifically, we theorize how women’s formal (their nations’ political ideologies) and informal (women’s empowerment) social standing within their societies influence gender discrimination in entrepreneurial bank financing. Consistent with most previous studies, our baseline results show that women entrepreneurs’ business loan applications are rejected to a greater extent than men entrepreneurs’ loan applications. Women entrepreneurs also pay higher interest rates on loans than men entrepreneurs. Further, in societies dominated by a conservative (rather than a liberal) political ideology, the positive relationship between women entrepreneurs and loan interest rates is more positive. Interestingly, gender discrimination in loan rejection and interest rates is magnified in societies with greater women’s empowerment. Taking a social gender-norm perspective, our analysis establishes a gender gap in entrepreneurial bank finance, and we outline an agenda for further research.
Empirical observational study · Women Who Shape Wealth · Digital finance & investor participation
Pomme Theunissen; Matteo Millone · 2024-07-10 · PLOS ONE
Crowdfunding is a growing source of finance for entrepreneurs. In this paper, we investigate the existence of a gender effect in the time needed to obtain a business loan through crowdfunding. Using data from three Dutch crowdfunding platforms, survival analysis of the time to completion for 934 business loan campaigns shows that female entrepreneurs have a 20% shorter campaign completion time compared to male entrepreneurs, whereas couples do not differ from males. This effect persists across the different platforms. Subsequent analysis shows that female entrepreneurs do not have the disadvantage they face in traditional lending channels when requesting funds through crowdfunding, and that herding behavior by investors benefits female entrepreneurs most.
Empirical observational study · Women Who Shape Wealth · Digital finance & investor participation
Jörg Prokop; Dandan Wang · 2021-11-19 · Small Business Economics
Compared to their male peers, female entrepreneurs tend to face greater obstacles in raising venture funding from business angels, venture capitalists, and financial institutions. In this paper, we investigate whether this gender gap also exists in equity crowdfunding. Based on data from the German equity crowdfunding market, we find that ventures with and without female managing directors are equally successful in raising capital when launching their first equity crowdfunding campaign. In contrast, the former are significantly less successful than their peers in seasoned equity crowdfunding campaigns, and this disparity cannot be fully explained by differences in other venture-related or entrepreneur-related characteristics. However, we also find that the gender gap in seasoned offerings narrows if female entrepreneurs set more ambitious funding thresholds. Overall, our results indicate that pitching their equity crowdfunding campaigns in a more promotion-oriented way is a sensible strategy for female entrepreneurs to improve funding success.
Empirical observational study · Women Who Shape Wealth · Digital finance & investor participation
Dandan Wang; Jörg Prokop · 2024-07-24 · Small Business Economics
We investigate gender-specific local biases among investors in equity crowdfunding. Based on data from a major German crowdfunding platform, we find that domestic investors favour ventures that are geographically closer to their own place of residence. This bias is particularly evident among female investors, although it is partially offset by gender homophily, whereby female investors favour companies with women in the top management team. Finally, we show that the introduction of the German Small Investor Protection Act may have exacerbated local biases in the German crowdfunding market, particularly with respect to firms with female management. Overall, our results suggest that establishing their companies in close proximity to a large number of potential female crowd investors may help improve female entrepreneurs’ chances of attracting equity crowdfunding investment.
Exploratory observational study · Women Who Shape Wealth · Digital finance & investor participation
Ali Mohammadi; Kourosh Shafi · 2017-01-20 · Small Business Economics
This paper is an exploratory attempt to understand gender-related differences in the behavior of investors in firms seeking equity financing. Using data from the Swedish equity crowdfunding platform FundedByMe, we find that female investors are less likely to invest in the equity of firms that are younger and high tech and have a higher percentage of equity offerings. This pattern seems consistent with a greater risk aversion in female versus male investors. Furthermore, female investors are more likely to invest in projects in which the proportion of male investors is higher.
Research article · Women Who Shape Wealth · Financial agency across generations
Shohei Okamoto; Kohei Komamura · 2021-11-17 · PLOS ONE
Financial knowledge, confidence and reported conduct differ across age and gender in a Japanese survey.
Research article · Women Who Shape Wealth · Financial agency across generations
Karla Cordova; Markus M. Grabka; Eva Sierminska · 2022-08-22 · European Journal of Population
We examine the gender wealth gap with a focus on pension wealth and statutory pension rights. By taking into account employment characteristics of women and men, we are able to identify the extent to which the redistributive effect of pension rights reduces the gender wealth gap. The data for our analysis come from the German Socio-Economic Panel (SOEP), one of the few surveys that collects information on wealth and pension entitlements at the individual level. Pension wealth data are available in the SOEP for 2012 only. While the relative raw gender wealth gap is about 35% (or 31,000 euros) when analysing the standard measure of net worth, it shrinks to 28% when pension wealth is added. This reduction is due to redistributive elements such as caregiver credits provided through the statutory pension scheme. Results of a recentred influence functions (RIF) decomposition show that pension wealth reduces the gap substantially in the lower half of the distribution. At the 90th percentile, the gender wealth gap in net worth and in augmented wealth remains more stable at roughly 27–30%.
Research article · Women Who Shape Wealth · Financial agency across generations
Li Jia; Wenjing Lei; Gerrit Antonides · 2025-10-09 · Journal of Family and Economic Issues
This study investigates the effect of women’s bargaining power on household stock investment. Using data from the 2019 wave of the China Household Finance Survey (CHFS), this study finds that women’s bargaining power within the household was positively related to household stock investment. Specifically, we explored the mediating effects of financial information attention and the moderating effects of risk preference and financial literacy on the relationship between women’s bargaining power and household stock investment. The results show that women's bargaining power improved household stock investment indirectly by increasing the spouses’ attention to economic and financial information. We also find that wives’ risk preference and financial literacy intensified the positive effect of women’s bargaining power on household stock investment. The positive relationship between women’s bargaining power and household stock investment was relatively strong for below-median wealthy households. In addition, the effect of women’s bargaining power on household stock investment intensified with the increasing age of the wives. A discussion of the results and implications for policy making are included.
Review article · Women Who Shape Wealth · Financial agency across generations
Oscar A. Stolper; Andreas Walter · 2017-03-04 · Journal of Business Economics
In this survey, we review the voluminous body of literature on the measurement and the determinants of financial literacy. Wherever possible, we supplement existing findings with recent descriptive evidence of German households’ financial literacy levels based on the novel Panel on Household Finances dataset, a large-scale survey administered by the Deutsche Bundesbank and representative of the financial situation of households in Germany. Prior research not only documents generally low levels of financial literacy but also finds large heterogeneity in financial literacy across the population, suggesting that economically vulnerable groups are placed at further disadvantage by their lack of financial knowledge. In addition, we assess the literature evaluating financial education as a means to improve financial literacy and financial behavior. Our survey suggests that the evidence with respect to the effectiveness of the programs is rather disappointing. We also review the role of individuals’ financial literacy for the use of professional financial advice and assess whether expert intervention can serve as a substitute to financial literacy. We conclude by discussing several directions for future research.
Research article · A Legacy Built to Last · Liquidity, debt & the freedom to wait
Dorinth W. van Dijk; Marc K. Francke · 2021-06-28 · The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics
Abstract We examine co-movements in private commercial real estate index returns and market liquidity in the US (apartment, office, retail) and for eighteen global cities, using data from Real Capital Analytics over the period 2005–2018. Our measure of market liquidity is based on the difference between supply and demand price indexes. We document for all analyzed markets much stronger commonalities in changes in market liquidity compared to commonalities in real price index returns. We further provide empirical evidence that space markets are less integrated than capital markets by analyzing co-movements in net-operating-income and cap rate spreads (over similar maturity bond yields). In a theoretical simulation model, we show that the strong integration of capital markets compared to space markets, is in fact the reason why market liquidity co-moves so strongly compared to returns. Our results are of interest for large private real estate investors such as pension funds and other institutional investors who are interested in spreading risk. Our findings imply that fully diversified price return benefits may be difficult to obtain, because market liquidity may dry up in all markets simultaneously, which makes portfolio re-balancing more difficult and costly.